Is DHCP on Linksys router + DNS on Server 2003 a problem?

I've been told that using a Linksys router (WRT54G) as the DHCP server on a network with Active Directory services and a Windows 2003 Server acting as the DNS server can be a problem.

The router connects to the Cbeyond Modem and a switch that the 2003 Server and all workstations are connected to.

The Windows 2003 server has 2 NIC cards but only one is connected to the network.

Are there potential issues with this setup?

What should be done to avoid DNS/DHCP issues in this case?
Who is Participating?
woolnoirConnect With a Mentor Commented:
lets say you have a domain ''
you have a client with a machine name of 'test'
if you have DHCP and DNS on the DC
and you get an address of

if you ping you will always resolve to the correct address, even if next time to restart it, it picks up 1.11, the ping to the DNS name will always work. The DHCP and DNS servers work together.

If you have separation, it doesnt work so well.
woolnoirConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Nah its fine, there are advantages to have DHCP and DNS both on domain controller as it links DHCP requests to DNS names so IP/Name resolution is kept consistent. You can have DHCP on seperate box (router) without issues.
woolnoirConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Just be sure you DONT have DHCP enabled on the DC at the same time, that will cause you issues, unless you have it configured for split scope.
asciiassasinAuthor Commented:
DHCP is not even set up on the server.  So all should be well.

But, are there advantages to having DHCP on the server over having it on the router?
I always use the DHCP server on server and the first reason is that it has more configuration options than DHCP server on linksys router.
Client DNS dynamic registration could be the problem if you are using windows 98 or Windows Me. Later operating systems are capable of dynamic DNS registration so they don't need DHCP server to do this for them.

Some more info here:
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.