RAID Query - Hard Drives

Hi EE,

Just a quick question regarding hard drives in a RAID group.
If we had a hard drive failure, and needs replacing, and we cannot source the same hard drive, do we just find a hard drive with same size and speed regardless of its model?

Who is Participating?
DavidConnect With a Mentor PresidentCommented:
This is a simple thing to do.  Look at the netgear site and check their HCL.  Surely they have qualified other 1TB disks.  

Save yourself the time and grief of risking data loss by just asking Netgear what 1TB HDDs they support.  But just any HDD will not do. Get a 'green' disk, or one with 4KB sectoring and you may end up regretting the decision because such things expose you to data loss.

Heck, windows software RAID won't support doing software RAID1 with a Seagate drive and just about any recent model of WD disk drive because the Seagates are 512 byte sectoring, and most of the consumer class WD drives have 4KB sectoring.  If you try to do this, it will give an error.  Think about it.  Firmware and settings matter more than you think, especially in a RAID config.
It's generally fine to use any drive as long as it's the same or bigger capacity.  Obviously you also want to it to be the same or better speed/specs so it doesn't bring the group down, but this isn't a requirement.  I've seen/used different drives plenty.
goraekAuthor Commented:
Thanks - what if the speed is greater, will this still work? Lets say I went from 7200 to 15000? Will this affect the rest of the raid?
Improved Protection from Phishing Attacks

WatchGuard DNSWatch reduces malware infections by detecting and blocking malicious DNS requests, improving your ability to protect employees from phishing attacks. Learn more about our newest service included in Total Security Suite today!

goraekAuthor Commented:
Also to add - if I want to upgrade the hard drives in the raid:

EG. 5 x 1TB 7200 to 5 x 2TB 15000 (will this be ok?)
No, it is not generally fine to just replace a HDD with any other HDD of >= capacity.   Best practice is to

1. Check the manufacturer to see what HDDs are specifically qualified.  Not all HDDs are the same, especially SATA drives.  Consumer SATA disks don't have the right firmware to work properly with most RAID controllers.

2. Assuming the 15K HDD is on manufacturer's supported list, then go for it.  The faster drive will result in slightly faster performance all around.
goraekAuthor Commented:

In my case, I have 2 x Seagate ST31000528AS 931 GB. One of them had died on me. And I need to replace it quick before the other one goes!

And I believe this particular model does not exist anymore (its been discontinued), however there are some out there, but I would rather upgrade the hard drive.

What is my best scenario?
goraekAuthor Commented:
By the way, the spec is SATA2, 32MB cache, 7200rpm. Would be good if I can upgrade. And its a Netgear ReadyNAS unit.
goraekAuthor Commented:
Thanks for the info
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.