ozihandicraft
asked on
ADCS vs. self-signed certificates
Hello -
I am at a cross road with our Digital Signature project. Our goal is to provide the ability to digitally sign in-house PDFs. The PDFs will not leave the organization.
Solution #1: I have installed and configured Active Directory Certificate Services and have been working out a problem with publishing the Delta CRL. This solution is still dysfunctional.
Solution #2: Another suggestion was made that I use self-signed certificates, created by Adobe, and placed on protected shares accessible to the various groups within our organization. When a PDF needs a signature the user may select his/her .pfx from the share & authenticate identify with password.
My question are:
1. Which method is preferred? I suspect #1 is more secure.
2. Is solution #2 a legitimate option?
3. What is your experience with either solution?
Thank you kindly
I am at a cross road with our Digital Signature project. Our goal is to provide the ability to digitally sign in-house PDFs. The PDFs will not leave the organization.
Solution #1: I have installed and configured Active Directory Certificate Services and have been working out a problem with publishing the Delta CRL. This solution is still dysfunctional.
Solution #2: Another suggestion was made that I use self-signed certificates, created by Adobe, and placed on protected shares accessible to the various groups within our organization. When a PDF needs a signature the user may select his/her .pfx from the share & authenticate identify with password.
My question are:
1. Which method is preferred? I suspect #1 is more secure.
2. Is solution #2 a legitimate option?
3. What is your experience with either solution?
Thank you kindly
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.