Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of iamuser
iamuser

asked on

Using SSD for video, is there any performance gain over HDD?

I read articles that say SSDs are going to go bad if you write/read to much as the life expectancy goes down faster due to video file sizes but then I see 4k cameras and capture devices that need require SSDs so I'm sort of confused. Anyway I'm wondering if this would net me any benefit

Capture 1080P/I video to computer with SSD drive

Take capture footage and export it to Pro Res format onto 2nd external SSD drive

Edit pro res file off of 2nd external SSD drive

Export/render file for final output to regular external USB 3.0 HDD
Avatar of MrC63
MrC63
Flag of Canada image

The specific task is not the important issue.  Whether you read / write video files, or CAD drawings, or anything (large or small) doesn't matter.  The concern with SSD drives, other than firmware, is known as write endurance (or write exhaustion, by some).  In other words, even though they have no moving parts, the memory components (NAND) will eventually lose their ability to hold power (and therefore not record) based on the number of P/E cycles (program / erase) the drive experiences -- regardless of what type of file is written (and / or erased).

Size of the drive will impact this, since each NAND on a larger drive will experience few P/E cycles.  The type of NAND is also important.  Studies have shown (and are readily available) that, with an 80 GB SSD drive using 3X MLC NAND will typically withstand 5000 P/E cycles.  That translates to about 114 TB of data written / erased from the drive.  

Assuming you write 10 GB per day to the drive, that would be 31 years before failure.

That's a bit of an oversimplification -- but it should help you understand the issues with SSD drive.  Brand matters, as does the firmware.  Power failures can also have an impact on SSD -- so be sure they are on a UPS if you want them to last.

Hopefully that helps you make a decision.

Mr.C
Avatar of iamuser
iamuser

ASKER

hmm I'll have to figure out the math to see who long an scandisk Extreme 240 GB ssd is going to last then
Is it an Extreme, Extreme II, or Extreme III.  Each uses different NAND's.
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of MrC63
MrC63
Flag of Canada image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of iamuser

ASKER

It is the base extreme SSD which is the 24 nand. The extreme II uses 19 nand size. Regular extreme uses the sandforce controller while II uses marvell. From what I understand the sandforce 22xx line of controllers are very slow when writing non-compressible data (liek video and etc). Not sure if they fixed that problem as I can't find any additional info on it. Thanks for the math formula.
SOLUTION
Avatar of Merete
Merete
Flag of Australia image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial