VFP 8 vs. VFP 9 ENGINEBEHAVIOR

I am having a problem where a query produces different results based on whether it's run in VFP 8 or VFP 9. Here is the query :

SELECT DISTINCT gage.gageno, gage.loc, gage.lastused, gage.duedate, gage.outofserv, gage.gagedesc, gage.customer, gagepart.partno
FROM gage LEFT JOIN gagepart ON ALLTRIM(gage.gageno) = ALLTRIM(gagepart.gageno)
WHERE LEFT(gage.gageno,6) == '13-01-' INTO CURSOR fred

The following are settings in both versions :

ANSI = OFF
EXACT = OFF
ENGINEBEHAVIOR = 70

When run in 9, the query includes a record where the GAGEPART table contains a record with a blank gageno field. When run in 8, it does not. I know I could rectify this by replacing the = in the JOIN clause with a ==, but I'm looking for the reason why this happens. Is there some other setting I need to look at ?

Any insight here would be appreciated.
AlanAronsAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
pcelbaCommented:
SET EXACT is not important here. Other settings which could affect the result are: SET COLLATE, CPCURRENT(), CPDBF(), and maybe SET DELETED.

The row having empty gagepart.gageno should be on output in all cases because SET ANSI OFF forces the string comparison to the length of the shorter of both strings - so if one of the strings contains just spaces the ALLTRIM converts it to zero length string and the JOIN condition must be True because you are comparing two zero length strings.

I cannot test this behavior in VFP 8 just now but I am sure VFP 9 has many previous bugs  fixed... so let say this was bug in SQL engine prior to VFP 9 (if this is not caused by Collation or Code Page settings).

SET ANSI ON removes blank gagepart.gageno records from output.
0
 
AlanAronsAuthor Commented:
I was afraid that might be the case.   It occurred to me that the result in 8 given the settings should be incorrect.   I was trying to avoid having to go through all of our code and try and find where this might apply.   Looks like we should turn ANSI on in the programs while still running in 8 (I can do it in the base class for the form.)  and see if it affects anything.  Then when we go to 9 it shouldn't have an effect.  

Thanks for your help.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.