Which Laserjet printer is better?

Hello Experts,

Can you tell me which Laserjet printer is better between the two below and why? I would like to get one of the two printer below and not sure which is a better.

Brother MFC 9340CDW Laser All in One:
http://www.staples.com/Brother-MFC-9340CDW-Laser-All-in-One-Printer/product_187953

HP Laserjet M451dn:
http://www.staples.com/HP-Color-Laserjet-M451dn-Printer/product_421682
LVL 4
asp_net2Asked:
Who is Participating?
 
Joe Winograd, EE Fellow 2017, MVE 2016, MVE 2015Connect With a Mentor DeveloperCommented:
Hi asp_net2,
These are not comparable devices. The Brother is a multi-function/all-in-one device. The HP is just a printer. So the first thing you need to decide is if you want a multi-function/all-in-one device or just a printer.

I've had no experience with these two particular units, so I can't give you any feedback based on actual usage. However, I've had several Brother MFCs during many years and have been very happy with the laser printer models – not the inkjet models. I have their current top-of-the-line color laser unit, the MFC-9970CDW:
http://www.staples.com/Brother-MFC-9970CDW-Color-Laser-All-in-One-Printer/product_887589

It is an excellent device! I suspect that the MFC-9340CDW that you're considering is also excellent, and based on my experience with several Brother (laser-based) models, I wouldn't hesitate to give the MFC-9340CDW a try.

Btw, if you do want a multi-function/all-in-one device, the HP unit comparable to the Brother MFC-9340CDW is probably the LaserJet Color MFP M475dn Multifunction Printer:
http://www.staples.com/HP-LaserJet-Color-MFP-M475dn-Multifunction-Printer/product_421681

Regards, Joe
0
 
KorbusCommented:
The major differences:
The Brother has the ability to scan, fax and copy, the HP does not.
The HP has a higher duty cycle, which generally means it's more rugged- printing wise.
Brother has wireless, HP does not (though both have networking)

You'll need to decide which of these factors has the most value for you.

That being said, I've always had fewer problems with HP printers, and I'm sure you could find an HP all-in-one laser.  They tend to cost a bit more, but I have found it worth it.
0
 
asp_net2Author Commented:
What about the drums between the two? The HP drum gets replaced every time you replace the toner cartridge whereas the brother you have to replace separately when needed. In other words when you replace the toner for the brother it does not replace the drum.

Also, the brother uses LED printing whereas the HP is listed as Laserjet. They both fall under the Laserjet category but the brother has LED printing if you look at its specs.

I never purchased a Laserjet printer before and just want to get a good Laserjet printer.
0
Hire Technology Freelancers with Gigs

Work with freelancers specializing in everything from database administration to programming, who have proven themselves as experts in their field. Hire the best, collaborate easily, pay securely, and get projects done right.

 
KorbusCommented:
"..just want to get a good Laserjet printer."  
Definately, get an HP.  

Though perhaps other experts will disagree.
0
 
asp_net2Author Commented:
Hi Joe,

Im not concerned about copy, scan, or fax. The two I chose are in my price range. I never owned a Laserjet printer and just want to get something reliable. The brother uses LED printing which I'm not sure if that is comparable to Laserjet printing, in other words I'm not sure if LED is better or worse compared to Laserjet.

Also, it appears the HP has a 10,000 page duty cycle higher than brother. Also, when you replace the toners in an HP you are also replacing the drums from what i was told.
0
 
Joe Winograd, EE Fellow 2017, MVE 2016, MVE 2015DeveloperCommented:
Yes, LED and laser printing are similar. Here's a very brief write-up in Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LED_printer

I'm sure a web search for "led vs laser printer" will turn up more detailed info for you to study.

Duty cycle is certainly an important issue, so you'll need to match those specs with your printing volume.

Based on what I've read, you are correct that the M451dn toner cartridges also contain the drums. But that probably makes them more expensive, so it's not clear that this is an advantage. It may be more cost-effective to replace just (lower-priced) toner cartridges and then the drum unit only when needed (on printers where they are separate, it's likely that the life of a drum exceeds the life of a toner cartridge). The cost of consumables can be a big issue with printers, so you may want to look for some data that compares per-page printing costs for the various printers you're considering. On the other hand, if you don't print a lot, the initial cost of the unit may be the far more important factor for you. Regards, Joe
0
All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.