asked on
HP DL380P / P420i Best SSD Configuration
Hello Folks,
I am setting up an HP DL380P / P420i server for ESXI and want to know if anyone has had any experience using 3rd party SSD's in this machine. I need 1TB of storage for 6VM's so was thinking of using 8 of either the Samsung 840 Pro SSD's or 8 of the Intel DC S3700 drives in RAID 10 to get maximum IOPs. Two of the VM's run databases so I want the best performance possible. I would go with genuine HP SSD's but it would cost me 10K just for the drives which is not in the budget. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
I am setting up an HP DL380P / P420i server for ESXI and want to know if anyone has had any experience using 3rd party SSD's in this machine. I need 1TB of storage for 6VM's so was thinking of using 8 of either the Samsung 840 Pro SSD's or 8 of the Intel DC S3700 drives in RAID 10 to get maximum IOPs. Two of the VM's run databases so I want the best performance possible. I would go with genuine HP SSD's but it would cost me 10K just for the drives which is not in the budget. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
VMwareWindows Server 2008Server Hardware
Last Comment
Andrew Hancock (VMware vExpert PRO / EE Fellow/British Beekeeper)
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
THIS SOLUTION ONLY AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS.
View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
HP are a bit behind on releasing the option to disable the RAID engine on Smart Array controllers to us plebs, it's easy enough to set them into non-RAID mode on Itanium based Integrity machines but on Xeon based ProLiants it's not possible and to use generic SSDs that would be the best option. The RAID intelligence of the controller just gets in the way with SSDs. There may be an option to use a JBOD controller in a slot and skip past HP's controller on boot by having nothing connected to it.
ASKER
Dear Andrew,
Thank you so much for your very informative and detailed post! A few questions:
1. What is the rough cost of the FusionIO IO-DriveDuo 640GB card?
2. Is the idea that I use the card INSTEAD of drives or in addition to?
3. Would it be overkill to run the SQL server on a separate host AND use the card?
Thanks!
Thank you so much for your very informative and detailed post! A few questions:
1. What is the rough cost of the FusionIO IO-DriveDuo 640GB card?
2. Is the idea that I use the card INSTEAD of drives or in addition to?
3. Would it be overkill to run the SQL server on a separate host AND use the card?
Thanks!
ASKER
Andrew....one more question. What about a dedicated DL380P SQL server running 2 SSD's in Raid1? Do you think RAID1 would give the same SSD issues you mentioned in your post?
1. $15k, smaller units are available, and also OCZ now also produce similar cards, although not sure if these have hit the VMware HCL as yet.
2. there is no requirement to use any disks for storage as the PCI-E card, is 640GB of Flash Storage, for use a a VMFS datastore for all your VMs. But you could use standard disks and create a datastore, and split the OS Drive and Database drive for DB and Logs on Flash. We actually use the entire flash datastore for VMs.
3. If you want even better performance, a physical host and Fusion-IO card will give even more performance.
2. there is no requirement to use any disks for storage as the PCI-E card, is 640GB of Flash Storage, for use a a VMFS datastore for all your VMs. But you could use standard disks and create a datastore, and split the OS Drive and Database drive for DB and Logs on Flash. We actually use the entire flash datastore for VMs.
3. If you want even better performance, a physical host and Fusion-IO card will give even more performance.
We have yet to find a successful combination using consumer SSDs and HP Smart Array controllers, and HP Support are little help in our labs, which we would consider stable for customer and production usage.
We've had some success using non-HP storage controllers (LSI), but the RAID storage controller BIOS clash with the HP Smart Array controller BIOS, so we are not able to configure RAID types.
You would need to test your combination of consumer SSD and Smart Array controller, and as HP seem to be closing the gap shortly on firmware updates, support seems to be getting more difficult on using non-HP parts in HP Servers! (which I suppose is to be expected, why would you want to use a desktop SSD in a server in the datacentre?)
We've had some success using non-HP storage controllers (LSI), but the RAID storage controller BIOS clash with the HP Smart Array controller BIOS, so we are not able to configure RAID types.
You would need to test your combination of consumer SSD and Smart Array controller, and as HP seem to be closing the gap shortly on firmware updates, support seems to be getting more difficult on using non-HP parts in HP Servers! (which I suppose is to be expected, why would you want to use a desktop SSD in a server in the datacentre?)
ASKER
Thanks!!! That is good to know. Given my budget, I think I will simply go with 4 15K drives in RAID 10 and a dedicated DL380P host for the SQL machine. Do you think that will give me decent performance? I will only have 4-6 users connecting to the machine but want it do respond to queries as fast as possible.
I think that will give you ample performance.
ASKER
Thank you for your clear feedback, Andrew!
No problems, and Happy New Year 2014!