• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 525
  • Last Modified:

Pros and cons of multi-site versus multiple site

I'm working on a set of products and services under the same root brand name, that will consume five domain names roughly like this(hopefully much prettier

Parent brand book

Parent brand services group all services
Parent brand services group Service one
Parent brand services group Service two
Parent brand services group Service three

All of these sites will be developed in different time frames and different intensities of attention

The books site will be a standalone brochure site which may or may not have links to the others.

The all services site will be a kind of catchall of ideas.

The services two site will get a lot of direct attention and effort.

The services one and three sites will be just development sites for a while, maybe forever.

Since these sites will be developed in different timings, and I can copy theme formats between sites, I'm thinking that I'm going to just make them multiple sites with links between them as needed.

The apple pie in the sky is that the three details Service sites take on lives of their own and it won't be that useful to have them be entangled.

What I was hoping for with this question was for E experts to provide some ideas about why I might or might not want to use multisite.

Any input on this would be appreciated.
Thanks!
0
codequest
Asked:
codequest
5 Solutions
 
South ModModeratorCommented:
codequest,

I changed the zones for this question from

--WordPress

to
--WordPress
--Web Languages/Standards
--Web Development


SouthMod
Community Support Moderator
0
 
Scott Fell, EE MVEDeveloper & EE ModeratorCommented:
Without knowing exactly what the products are and domains it is hard to say.  If they are all similar, one domain name.  If they are different products that are not related, multiple domain names/multiple sites.

If your site is about Apples, and you want to have sub topics like Apple Pie, Apple Sauce, Carmel Apples, and choosing the right apple, in this case, you want just one website with multiple topics.  

Apples.com/ApplePie
Apples.com/AppleSauce
Apples.com/CarmelApple
Apples.com/ChooseApples


If your first site is Apples, but you have other topics like Cars, Jobs, Computers then you want to have multiple domains and multiple sites.
0
 
David Johnson, CD, MVPOwnerCommented:
Main Site with subsites (Multi-Site)
Ease of editing all link references are updated less chance of forgetting one.
All hosted on the same web server instance and usually same sql server instance / database
Cookies, cached content is seamless

Multiple sites
Editing a link on one site means having to manually update other sites
Multiple webserver instances and multiple sql server instances / databases
0
Get 10% Off Your First Squarespace Website

Ready to showcase your work, publish content or promote your business online? With Squarespace’s award-winning templates and 24/7 customer service, getting started is simple. Head to Squarespace.com and use offer code ‘EXPERTS’ to get 10% off your first purchase.

 
Aaron TomoskySD-WAN SimplifiedCommented:
Multisite is easier to keep things the same, like links already mentioned. Multiple sites is easier to keep different. So if these will be done at different times then you don't want changes to a new one to mess with the old ones. If you are doing themes and other back end stuff, then if say go seperate. If you are just doing content, then you could keep it together.
0
 
codequestAuthor Commented:
Thanks for the inputs.  Those are helpful.

This one is probably a real hairsplitter.   The following is me thinking out loud.

Being a little less opaque, the domains are based on the pseudnomynous "Lifestylebrand:

LifeStyleConcept.com (for the LifeStyleConcept book)
(hyphens will not be used in the following, I'm including them here for clarity)
LifeStyleConcept-AllAreas.com
LifeStyleConcept-Food.com
LifeStyleConcept-Clothes.com
LifeStyleConcept-Home.com

The purposes of these sites are
1) promote the LifeStyleConcept book (1st and foremost)
2) share ideas about LifeStyleConcept in the -All Areas, -Food, -Clothes and -Home areas
3) develop a community to increase awareness of LifeStyleConcept
4) obtain ad revenue
5) develop the opportunity to create a substantial brand identity for "LifeStyleConcept-Clothes (including possible partnership with a clothing manufacturer).

LifeStyleConcept .com will be a book brochure and gateway to the other domains.  I feel a need to keep it "light" and flexible, i.e. concerned about "one big database".

-AllAreas domain will be an anything goes blog
-Food and -Home will be sites for articles specific to -Food and -Home
-Clothes will be a site for articles, blog and community specific to Clothes;  it is expected to have an order of magnitude more content and attention than -Food and -Home

So, based on that, there are two remaining questions:

>  How hard is it to split a multi-site sub-site into a single site?  That seems do-able:
https://managewp.com/split-multisite

>  Can you use separate domain names on sub-sites?  That seems do-able:
http://ottopress.com/2010/wordpress-3-0-multisite-domain-mapping-tutorial/

So, based on that, I can start with any combination, and change it later.   What I'll probably do is...look at just how hard the separate domain name and splitting issues are, because it would clearly be easier to have fewer sites to deal with, to begin with.

Any further comments would be welcome, however, I'm feeling fairly resolved at this point.

Thanks!
0
 
Scott Fell, EE MVEDeveloper & EE ModeratorCommented:
You can certainly have subdomains like food.mydomain.com and home.mydomain.com and they are treated as separate domains.

Since your overall brand is lifelstyle and you are trying to sell one book.  The more content you can have on one site the better.  If you split them up, you are not casting a bigger net.  You now have to spend 4 times as much on marketing and promotion.

Do you see bass pro shop with a fishing site, a boat site, a gun site, a clothing site?  

Spend your energy to have one big site with a lot of content.  Instead of subdomains or new domains, use pages

LifeStyleConcept.com\
LifeStyleConcept.com\Food\recipes
LifeStyleConcept.com\Food\spicy
LifeStyleConcept.com\Food\wine
LifeStyleConcept.com\Clothes\womens
LifeStyleConcept.com\Clothes\mens
LifeStyleConcept.com\Home\country
LifeStyleConcept.com\Home\smallspaces
LifeStyleConcept.com\Home\urban
0
 
Scott Fell, EE MVEDeveloper & EE ModeratorCommented:
This is a good example http://www.marthastewart.com/

If you mouse over the main areas, cook, create, celebrate, and shop you can see the areas she has direct control over are on one page.  The martha stewart living, pets et el all link to the companies that license her name.  But the other categories and subcategories stay on the site.

A newspaper site is also a good example http://www.huffingtonpost.com/  There are sections that look different, but all under the same domain.
0
 
codequestAuthor Commented:
Great input, Scott, and very appropriate.  FYI, my partner laughed; shares a birthday with Martha.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

Easily Design & Build Your Next Website

Squarespace’s all-in-one platform gives you everything you need to express yourself creatively online, whether it is with a domain, website, or online store. Get started with your free trial today, and when ready, take 10% off your first purchase with offer code 'EXPERTS'.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now