Avatar of convergint
Flag for United States of America asked on

Storage Spaces, SOFS and Shared SAS JBOD Redundancy

I've spent many hours online reading different articles on Server 2012 R2 storage spaces so please refrain from posting links as I need more real world comments and experiences.

My goal is to have two servers for Scale-Out File Server (SOFS) clustering using storage spaces connecting to two JBOD enclosures with full redundancy.  I understand that you need a JBOD enclosure without any RAID abstract layer for the server and to get full redundancy you would need a shared SAS controller to allow each server a connection to each enclosure.

It seems like you also need to use the enclosure awareness feature to support the failover of an enclosure but for some odd reason it requires three enclosures (yes I've read the MS articles but it still doesn't make 100% sense).  The HCL list is also pretty sparse right now with only DataON, RAIDInc, Fujitsu and a few others officially supported.  http://blogs.technet.com/b/privatecloud/archive/2013/04/05/windows-server-2012-about-clustered-storage-spaces-issue.aspx shows an example of two servers and two enclosures but I don't get how it would be possible to have three enclosures.  All the sparse hardware I've found seem to only support two SAS connections per enclosure.  I'm assuming that the theory is supported by Microsoft but there's no easily obtainable hardware that exists yet.

Would it be possible to have each server connect to only one enclosure and then mirror the storage spaces enclosure on each sever?  If the SOFS is clustered over the two servers, shouldn't it be able to handle an enclosure failure?  Finding a shared SAS controller doesn't seem to be easy and I do not want to use a SAS switch as that is another single point of failure.

Has anyone tried storage spaces with a Tier 1 manufacturer's enclosure, ie Dell, HP and make it work in a JBOD?  I am hesitant to use DataON and RaidInc as I have no experience with these manufacturers and worried about support.
Windows Server 2012ComponentsServer HardwareDell

Avatar of undefined
Last Comment

8/22/2022 - Mon
Cliff Galiher

View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
See Pricing Options
Start Free Trial
Ask your own question & get feedback from real experts
Find out why thousands trust the EE community with their toughest problems.

I assume that it is at least possible to have two different storage spaces on two different servers each with their own enclosure?  What about using software to mirror a virtual SAN over the two storage spaces like Starwind?  

I guess I'm asking a bit too much at this point to have no single points of failure using all built-in Server 2012 R2 components with Tier 1 manufacturers to build a SAN with reasonable costs.  I hate how most SAN manufacturers lock you into their products and the high price for what you actually get.  I totally understand how Dell and HP don't really want to support this as it takes away from their propriety SAN solutions.

The only SAS switch I have seen is the LSI SAS6160, have you used that before?  Thanks for your honest input.
Cliff Galiher

While you could use 3rd party software to mirror data, by doing different storage spaces and mirroring, failover would not be as automatic nor would it fit my definition of "scale out" for purposes of a SOFS build. There are benefits and drawbacks to such a solution.

I've not used that particular SAS switch.

It's definitely not "scale out" and that's fine with me but it should be automatic failover as the Starwind will take care of the mirroring and the Windows Clustering will utilize the Starwind "SAN".  It does add another layer of complexity no doubt.

I know thousands of places use a SAN with Microsoft Clustering but I just hate the fact that the SAN itself is a single point of failure and unfortunately I don't have a budget to allow for two expensive SANs.

Thanks for the input.
I started with Experts Exchange in 2004 and it's been a mainstay of my professional computing life since. It helped me launch a career as a programmer / Oracle data analyst
William Peck