Solved

Math: Number of possible combinations when sorted alphabetically

Posted on 2014-02-03
5
402 Views
Last Modified: 2014-02-03
I have 17 items:
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQ
I am working on a project that combines PDF documents in order, and I need to know how many total options would be possible.

There can be any combination of them, providing each item can only appear in the list once and the results are always in alphabetical order.

For example these would all be valid,
ACB
ACE
BFJ

But these would not be valid:
BBB
BCA

How can the number of options be calculated?
0
Comment
Question by:hankknight
[X]
Welcome to Experts Exchange

Add your voice to the tech community where 5M+ people just like you are talking about what matters.

  • Help others & share knowledge
  • Earn cash & points
  • Learn & ask questions
5 Comments
 
LVL 14

Assisted Solution

by:John-Charles-Herzberg
John-Charles-Herzberg earned 20 total points
ID: 39829948
Combinations without repetition (n=17, r=3)

List has 680 entries.
{a,b,c} {a,b,d} {a,b,e} {a,b,f} {a,b,g} {a,b,h} {a,b,i} {a,b,j} {a,b,k} {a,b,l} {a,b,m} {a,b,n} {a,b,o} {a,b,p} {a,b,q} {a,c,d} {a,c,e} {a,c,f} {a,c,g} {a,c,h} {a,c,i} {a,c,j} {a,c,k} {a,c,l} {a,c,m} {a,c,n} {a,c,o} {a,c,p} {a,c,q} {a,d,e} {a,d,f} {a,d,g} {a,d,h} {a,d,i} {a,d,j} {a,d,k} {a,d,l} {a,d,m} {a,d,n} {a,d,o} {a,d,p} {a,d,q} {a,e,f} {a,e,g} {a,e,h} {a,e,i} {a,e,j} {a,e,k} {a,e,l} {a,e,m} {a,e,n} {a,e,o} {a,e,p} {a,e,q} {a,f,g} {a,f,h} {a,f,i} {a,f,j} {a,f,k} {a,f,l} {a,f,m} {a,f,n} {a,f,o} {a,f,p} {a,f,q} {a,g,h} {a,g,i} {a,g,j} {a,g,k} {a,g,l} {a,g,m} {a,g,n} {a,g,o} {a,g,p} {a,g,q} {a,h,i} {a,h,j} {a,h,k} {a,h,l} {a,h,m} {a,h,n} {a,h,o} {a,h,p} {a,h,q} {a,i,j} {a,i,k} {a,i,l} {a,i,m} {a,i,n} {a,i,o} {a,i,p} {a,i,q} {a,j,k} {a,j,l} {a,j,m} {a,j,n} {a,j,o} {a,j,p} {a,j,q} {a,k,l} {a,k,m} {a,k,n} {a,k,o} {a,k,p} {a,k,q} {a,l,m} {a,l,n} {a,l,o} {a,l,p} {a,l,q} {a,m,n} {a,m,o} {a,m,p} {a,m,q} {a,n,o} {a,n,p} {a,n,q} {a,o,p} {a,o,q} {a,p,q} {b,c,d} {b,c,e} {b,c,f} {b,c,g} {b,c,h} {b,c,i} {b,c,j} {b,c,k} {b,c,l} {b,c,m} {b,c,n} {b,c,o} {b,c,p} {b,c,q} {b,d,e} {b,d,f} {b,d,g} {b,d,h} {b,d,i} {b,d,j} {b,d,k} {b,d,l} {b,d,m} {b,d,n} {b,d,o} {b,d,p} {b,d,q} {b,e,f} {b,e,g} {b,e,h} {b,e,i} {b,e,j} {b,e,k} {b,e,l} {b,e,m} {b,e,n} {b,e,o} {b,e,p} {b,e,q} {b,f,g} {b,f,h} {b,f,i} {b,f,j} {b,f,k} {b,f,l} {b,f,m} {b,f,n} {b,f,o} {b,f,p} {b,f,q} {b,g,h} {b,g,i} {b,g,j} {b,g,k} {b,g,l} {b,g,m} {b,g,n} {b,g,o} {b,g,p} {b,g,q} {b,h,i} {b,h,j} {b,h,k} {b,h,l} {b,h,m} {b,h,n} {b,h,o} {b,h,p} {b,h,q} {b,i,j} {b,i,k} {b,i,l} {b,i,m} {b,i,n} {b,i,o} {b,i,p} {b,i,q} {b,j,k} {b,j,l} {b,j,m} {b,j,n} {b,j,o} {b,j,p} {b,j,q} {b,k,l} {b,k,m} {b,k,n} {b,k,o} {b,k,p} {b,k,q} {b,l,m} {b,l,n} {b,l,o} {b,l,p} {b,l,q} {b,m,n} {b,m,o} {b,m,p} {b,m,q} {b,n,o} {b,n,p} {b,n,q} {b,o,p} {b,o,q} {b,p,q} {c,d,e} {c,d,f} {c,d,g} {c,d,h} {c,d,i} {c,d,j} {c,d,k} {c,d,l} {c,d,m} {c,d,n} {c,d,o} {c,d,p} {c,d,q} {c,e,f} {c,e,g} {c,e,h} {c,e,i} {c,e,j} {c,e,k} {c,e,l} {c,e,m} {c,e,n} {c,e,o} {c,e,p} {c,e,q} {c,f,g} {c,f,h} {c,f,i} {c,f,j} {c,f,k} {c,f,l} {c,f,m} {c,f,n} {c,f,o} {c,f,p} {c,f,q} {c,g,h} {c,g,i} {c,g,j} {c,g,k} {c,g,l} {c,g,m} {c,g,n} {c,g,o} {c,g,p} {c,g,q} {c,h,i} {c,h,j} {c,h,k} {c,h,l} {c,h,m} {c,h,n} {c,h,o} {c,h,p} {c,h,q} {c,i,j} {c,i,k} {c,i,l} {c,i,m} {c,i,n} {c,i,o} {c,i,p} {c,i,q} {c,j,k} {c,j,l} {c,j,m} {c,j,n} {c,j,o} {c,j,p} {c,j,q} {c,k,l} {c,k,m} {c,k,n} {c,k,o} {c,k,p} {c,k,q} {c,l,m} {c,l,n} {c,l,o} {c,l,p} {c,l,q} {c,m,n} {c,m,o} {c,m,p} {c,m,q} {c,n,o} {c,n,p} {c,n,q} {c,o,p} {c,o,q} {c,p,q} {d,e,f} {d,e,g} {d,e,h} {d,e,i} {d,e,j} {d,e,k} {d,e,l} {d,e,m} {d,e,n} {d,e,o} {d,e,p} {d,e,q} {d,f,g} {d,f,h} {d,f,i} {d,f,j} {d,f,k} {d,f,l} {d,f,m} {d,f,n} {d,f,o} {d,f,p} {d,f,q} {d,g,h} {d,g,i} {d,g,j} {d,g,k} {d,g,l} {d,g,m} {d,g,n} {d,g,o} {d,g,p} {d,g,q} {d,h,i} {d,h,j} {d,h,k} {d,h,l} {d,h,m} {d,h,n} {d,h,o} {d,h,p} {d,h,q} {d,i,j} {d,i,k} {d,i,l} {d,i,m} {d,i,n} {d,i,o} {d,i,p} {d,i,q} {d,j,k} {d,j,l} {d,j,m} {d,j,n} {d,j,o} {d,j,p} {d,j,q} {d,k,l} {d,k,m} {d,k,n} {d,k,o} {d,k,p} {d,k,q} {d,l,m} {d,l,n} {d,l,o} {d,l,p} {d,l,q} {d,m,n} {d,m,o} {d,m,p} {d,m,q} {d,n,o} {d,n,p} {d,n,q} {d,o,p} {d,o,q} {d,p,q} {e,f,g} {e,f,h} {e,f,i} {e,f,j} {e,f,k} {e,f,l} {e,f,m} {e,f,n} {e,f,o} {e,f,p} {e,f,q} {e,g,h} {e,g,i} {e,g,j} {e,g,k} {e,g,l} {e,g,m} {e,g,n} {e,g,o} {e,g,p} {e,g,q} {e,h,i} {e,h,j} {e,h,k} {e,h,l} {e,h,m} {e,h,n} {e,h,o} {e,h,p} {e,h,q} {e,i,j} {e,i,k} {e,i,l} {e,i,m} {e,i,n} {e,i,o} {e,i,p} {e,i,q} {e,j,k} {e,j,l} {e,j,m} {e,j,n} {e,j,o} {e,j,p} {e,j,q} {e,k,l} {e,k,m} {e,k,n} {e,k,o} {e,k,p} {e,k,q} {e,l,m} {e,l,n} {e,l,o} {e,l,p} {e,l,q} {e,m,n} {e,m,o} {e,m,p} {e,m,q} {e,n,o} {e,n,p} {e,n,q} {e,o,p} {e,o,q} {e,p,q} {f,g,h} {f,g,i} {f,g,j} {f,g,k} {f,g,l} {f,g,m} {f,g,n} {f,g,o} {f,g,p} {f,g,q} {f,h,i} {f,h,j} {f,h,k} {f,h,l} {f,h,m} {f,h,n} {f,h,o} {f,h,p} {f,h,q} {f,i,j} {f,i,k} {f,i,l} {f,i,m} {f,i,n} {f,i,o} {f,i,p} {f,i,q} {f,j,k} {f,j,l} {f,j,m} {f,j,n} {f,j,o} {f,j,p} {f,j,q} {f,k,l} {f,k,m} {f,k,n} {f,k,o} {f,k,p} {f,k,q} {f,l,m} {f,l,n} {f,l,o} {f,l,p} {f,l,q} {f,m,n} {f,m,o} {f,m,p} {f,m,q} {f,n,o} {f,n,p} {f,n,q} {f,o,p} {f,o,q} {f,p,q} {g,h,i} {g,h,j} {g,h,k} {g,h,l} {g,h,m} {g,h,n} {g,h,o} {g,h,p} {g,h,q} {g,i,j} {g,i,k} {g,i,l} {g,i,m} {g,i,n} {g,i,o} {g,i,p} {g,i,q} {g,j,k} {g,j,l} {g,j,m} {g,j,n} {g,j,o} {g,j,p} {g,j,q} {g,k,l} {g,k,m} {g,k,n} {g,k,o} {g,k,p} {g,k,q} {g,l,m} {g,l,n} {g,l,o} {g,l,p} {g,l,q} {g,m,n} {g,m,o} {g,m,p} {g,m,q} {g,n,o} {g,n,p} {g,n,q} {g,o,p} {g,o,q} {g,p,q} {h,i,j} {h,i,k} {h,i,l} {h,i,m} {h,i,n} {h,i,o} {h,i,p} {h,i,q} {h,j,k} {h,j,l} {h,j,m} {h,j,n} {h,j,o} {h,j,p} {h,j,q} {h,k,l} {h,k,m} {h,k,n} {h,k,o} {h,k,p} {h,k,q} {h,l,m} {h,l,n} {h,l,o} {h,l,p} {h,l,q} {h,m,n} {h,m,o} {h,m,p} {h,m,q} {h,n,o} {h,n,p} {h,n,q} {h,o,p} {h,o,q} {h,p,q} {i,j,k} {i,j,l} {i,j,m} {i,j,n} {i,j,o} {i,j,p} {i,j,q} {i,k,l} {i,k,m} {i,k,n} {i,k,o} {i,k,p} {i,k,q} {i,l,m} {i,l,n} {i,l,o} {i,l,p} {i,l,q} {i,m,n} {i,m,o} {i,m,p} {i,m,q} {i,n,o} {i,n,p} {i,n,q} {i,o,p} {i,o,q} {i,p,q} {j,k,l} {j,k,m} {j,k,n} {j,k,o} {j,k,p} {j,k,q} {j,l,m} {j,l,n} {j,l,o} {j,l,p} {j,l,q} {j,m,n} {j,m,o} {j,m,p} {j,m,q} {j,n,o} {j,n,p} {j,n,q} {j,o,p} {j,o,q} {j,p,q} {k,l,m} {k,l,n} {k,l,o} {k,l,p} {k,l,q} {k,m,n} {k,m,o} {k,m,p} {k,m,q} {k,n,o} {k,n,p} {k,n,q} {k,o,p} {k,o,q} {k,p,q} {l,m,n} {l,m,o} {l,m,p} {l,m,q} {l,n,o} {l,n,p} {l,n,q} {l,o,p} {l,o,q} {l,p,q} {m,n,o} {m,n,p} {m,n,q} {m,o,p} {m,o,q} {m,p,q} {n,o,p} {n,o,q} {n,p,q} {o,p,q}

If you need more information.  The calculator can be found at:

Combinations and Permutations Calculator

http://www.mathsisfun.com/combinatorics/combinations-permutations-calculator.html

Thanks
JC
0
 
LVL 84

Assisted Solution

by:ozo
ozo earned 20 total points
ID: 39829985
17!/(17-3)!/3!
0
 
LVL 32

Accepted Solution

by:
phoffric earned 360 total points
ID: 39830000
>> the results are always in alphabetical order.
>> ACB
   Why is this allowed? Shouldn't it be ABC?

If you want options that are larger than 3 (or even 2, or just 1), then the total number of options is 2^17 less 1. To see why, take a binary word that is 17 bits long. If you select ABDE, then that could map to:
11011000000000000

To select all options, you would select all possibilities of 1's and 0's. There are 2^17 such possibilities. One of those possibilities is all 0's which means none are selected. That is why the total number of options is 2^17 less 1.
0
 
LVL 37

Assisted Solution

by:TommySzalapski
TommySzalapski earned 100 total points
ID: 39830004
Are you always selecting three?
If you can select any number, than the total possible combinations is
2^17 (which includes the case where you select none and the one where you select all)
So valid cases
[blank]
A
B
AB
ACDG
GHPQ
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQ
etc

Oops phoffric beat me to the punch.
0
 
LVL 16

Author Comment

by:hankknight
ID: 39830028
Thank you-- 2 to the power of 17 minus one is the answer I was looking for.
0

Featured Post

Want Experts Exchange at your fingertips?

With Experts Exchange’s latest app release, you can now experience our most recent features, updates, and the same community interface while on-the-go. Download our latest app release at the Android or Apple stores today!

Question has a verified solution.

If you are experiencing a similar issue, please ask a related question

This article demonstrates how to create a simple responsive confirmation dialog with Ok and Cancel buttons using HTML, CSS, jQuery and Promises
Boost your ability to deliver ambitious and competitive web apps by choosing the right JavaScript framework to best suit your project’s needs.
The viewer will learn the basics of jQuery, including how to invoke it on a web page. Reference your jQuery libraries: (CODE) Include your new external js/jQuery file: (CODE) Write your first lines of code to setup your site for jQuery.: (CODE)
Although Jacob Bernoulli (1654-1705) has been credited as the creator of "Binomial Distribution Table", Gottfried Leibniz (1646-1716) did his dissertation on the subject in 1666; Leibniz you may recall is the co-inventor of "Calculus" and beat Isaac…
Suggested Courses

623 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question