• Status: Solved
• Priority: Medium
• Security: Public
• Views: 4883

Incorrect sum value returned on sumifs function calculation in microsoft excel

I have been getting incorrect totals returned on a sumifs calculation on random instances in Microsoft Office Excel 2013. The issue present is that we use producer price index commodity codes and assign inventory for our clients the appropriate PPI code for each unique inventory row in excel. The sumifs we use totals the \$(dollars) for each PPI(Producer Price Index) commodity code in a separate sheet in order to run our Inventory Calculation software. Can anyone shed light upon the attached file, or has experienced what we are dealing wit, or why it would occur?
Example-of-sumif---countif-error.xlsx
0
Lee Richardson
• 2
• 2
• 2
• +1
2 Solutions

Commented:
Replace the single quote ' by double quote "
Excel still sees your figures as number you want them to be string or text then let it be
check the file
gowflow
Example-of-sumif---countif-error.xlsx
0

Commented:
use
=SUMPRODUCT((A\$5:A\$8=A12)+0,B\$5:B\$8) for the sumif

the countif is more tricky and there's probably a more elegant solution but if you add a helper column "c" which has a 1 against every PPI entry you can use

=SUMPRODUCT((A\$5:A\$8=A12)+0,C\$5:C\$8

If you can modify the PPI code - or use a helper column again- then adding any character to the front of the code - to hide the leading 0 = would make sumif/countif work as normal
0

Commented:
I agree with regmigrant - SUMIF and COUNTIF typically don't distinguish between text and number, and will treat numbers stored as text values as the equivalent number - 2 = "02" etc. so if you need to do that use SUMPRODUCT which will distinguish.

For the COUNTIF you can use simply

=SUMPRODUCT((A\$5:A\$8=A19)+0)

regards, barry
0

Owner & PresidentAuthor Commented:
Thank you for the advice on the SUMPRODUCT() function usage. It did fix the immediate issue. We had created a test file that was intended for showing someone via email, and had reduced the complexity file size (in order for it to be small enough to send in Microsoft Outlook as an attachment). The actual "sumifs" calculation is what created an error. I should have posted this file, but did not. It has an additional criteria which searches for the "Pool Number" column in order to populate the proper results. There are three different pools this company uses, and we can not lump the PPI codes all in as one pool. The attached file I have shows the example. I am not sure if SUMPRODUCT() would work on this sumifs error due to the fact that it has multiple parameters. Thanks for your advice, and I would happily accept any additional guidance from this error.
Dec2012DIS-TestOfSumifs.xlsx
0

Commented:
this is a huge file ! 23.9 mb and u expect someone to download this ???
0

Commented:
You can use SUMPRODUCT for summing or counting with multiple criteria, just like SUMIFS or COUNTIFS.....but it will be slower, e.g. this formula will sum including the "Pool number" criteion

=SUMPRODUCT((UniqueList!\$E\$2:\$E\$71724=A8)*(UniqueList!\$D\$2:\$D\$71724=B8),UniqueList!\$G\$2:\$G\$71724)

regards, barry
0

Owner & PresidentAuthor Commented:
Works like a charm now; your a lifesaver, Barry! Thank you very much.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.