To Update Or Not - That is the Question

I have an XP-SP3 PC.
I have not updated windows in at least 5 years.
I ran windows update and approximately 175 updates are listed.
It seems like a lot of updates in one go.

Should I update, and if I do, might I regret it?

I have created a restore point (and image) but I'm still wary.
LVL 24
EirmanChief Operations ManagerAsked:
Who is Participating?
IT_admin_031Connect With a Mentor Commented:
There are many reasons you should, but It is more of personal viewpoint rather than if you should.

I believe you should. There are probably more than just 175 though. After you update those, there will probably be another 100 or so. Reasons you should:

1. vulnerabilities - if you go to a malicious website you will more than likely end up with some web STD.
2. you won't have long to get the updates - April is the deadline.
3. Lawsuits - Microsoft patches things for a reason. Some reasons are from infringed code that others have copywrite protections. If you don't update (Like office 2007 sp3) you can be held liable for using the infringing code.
4. enhanced features - Even though a lot of negativity swarms updates, they do improve program features when applied correctly.

This is what I believe you fear.
If the updates don't apply correctly, you may lose some reliability. All hardware/software come into play with that though. how a program is installed, what that program affects when it is installed, then how an update from Microsoft affects that. If your program relies on a windows DLL that microsoft finds a vulnerability in, then patches the DLL, it will likely affect that program.

If you have already captured an image and a restore point, I don't see the harm. I have patched thousands of machines through WSUS, and about 1-5% have problems, but most of those are from bad software that was already installed, faulty hardware or a 3rd party drivers.
Good luck either way.
aadihConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Not to update is not an option. :-)
Scott ThompsonConnect With a Mentor Computer Technician / OwnerCommented:
If your computer is on the internet, then yes, I would recommend updating it.  This will give you the best protection against infection (for XP) and will also allow websites to display properly (at least for the time being).

Here's a couple of articles explaining some of the benefits of upgrading to a newer system as Windows XP ends support
Cloud Class® Course: SQL Server Core 2016

This course will introduce you to SQL Server Core 2016, as well as teach you about SSMS, data tools, installation, server configuration, using Management Studio, and writing and executing queries.

EirmanChief Operations ManagerAuthor Commented:
I know XP Support end in April. This is an oldish machine and will never be upgraded.
Besides, I'll always need one PC with XP for customer support purposes.

I'm just worried that I could run into problems when doing so many updates in the one go.
n2fcConnect With a Mentor Commented:
If you are that concerned, just do the recommended security updates as these are essential for computer health & safety...

You can save the optional updates for another time (if at all)...

As a side issue, Microsoft has relented and agreed to supply updates to Microsoft Security Essentials (AKA Windows Defender) for XP for yet another year (although the install file will not be available after support drops).


EirmanChief Operations ManagerAuthor Commented:
I'm running all the updates at the moment.

I'll let you all know how it went in a few hours.
I'm running all the updates. ~ Eirman

Great. You are doing it. :-)
EirmanChief Operations ManagerAuthor Commented:
Thanks IT_admin_031

It's @ #88 .... That ms server is so slow!
Gary CaseConnect With a Mentor RetiredCommented:
You've already done what I'd have recommended -- made an image, so it's possible to restore to the "as was" state if needed.    But you not only SHOULD do all the updates (as you're already doing) ... but you should do them again every week until the final set is issued in April ==> THEN you should image your "clean, fully up-to-date as of EOL" copy of XP.

Then if you ever need to restore it, it's just a matter of restoring the image -- which, of course, you should have stored in at least two places.
Come April, the question becomes: To XP or not to XP?

And the answer to this is also an obvious one. Practically, objectively speaking.  :-)
Gary CaseConnect With a Mentor RetiredCommented:
"... Come April, the question becomes: To XP or not to XP?
... And the answer to this is also an obvious one."

Not necessarily.   For anyone who's in the business of supporting computers, I agree completely with the author's comment, "...  I'll always need one PC with XP for customer support purposes."

... and that will be true for several more years.    XP support is ending ... but that does not in any way mean that XP computers won't still be useful, and indeed still used by a LOT of folks !!
Of course, garycase. Undoubtedly.  The special cases will always remain; my comment was for general use by the masses (not so obvious as I thought). :-)
EirmanChief Operations ManagerAuthor Commented:
Thanks everyone.

After 6 hours of painfully slow downloading, two reboots and some testing, everything seems to be okay.
Great. You did it. :-)
Good for you Eirman - Next we will get you setup with a WSUS server so that all the updates will be downloaded to your machine, installed and rebooted in 30 minutes. :-) Thanks for the points!
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.