• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 557
  • Last Modified:

Stability of Windows RAID 1?

Hello all,

   a question nregardgint MS Windows software RAID 1 implementation.

   How stable it is?
   And what about disaster recovery - can other win computers read fallen Windows RIAD 1 member drives?

   I have an old server to manage and limited resources, so I wanted to migrate DATA to a software raid array.


Thank you!
0
mrmut
Asked:
mrmut
  • 5
  • 4
  • 2
1 Solution
 
Alex Green3rd Line Server SupportCommented:
Well I wouldn't use RAID1 to start with anyway since you'll end up using up double the disk space, RAID5 would be better.

As for software raid, if it were on a UNIX box then I'd say go for it... Windows... Meh, probably not.
0
 
mrmutAuthor Commented:
This is not an answer to the Q :-)
0
 
Alex Green3rd Line Server SupportCommented:
How asked how stable it is, I'm saying that I wouldn't recommend it due to the fact that it isn't particularly good.

Firstly you can't access the data until the OS is up and running since it's software based, attaching the disks to another machine and then accessing the data is possible.

Plug the disks in, get into windows, open up disk management and right click and then rescan disks. That will then bring up the software RAID array.

However this is a terrible idea and windows software RAID isn't very good. It's slow, you can't access the array without windows (No chance of a disk scrape either) and RAID1 for data is pointless.

Does that answer your question better? :D

Regards

Alex
0
Ultimate Tool Kit for Technology Solution Provider

Broken down into practical pointers and step-by-step instructions, the IT Service Excellence Tool Kit delivers expert advice for technology solution providers. Get your free copy now.

 
mrmutAuthor Commented:
Does that answer your question better? :D

YES! :-)
0
 
Alex Green3rd Line Server SupportCommented:
:-)

Thanks bro, you have a good day :D

Regards

Alex
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
RAID1 simply mirrors the data from a hdd to the other.
Windows's implementation is as good as any other soft/fake implementation.
It's stable. Didn't had disks "jump out of RAID", like on some on-board controllers.

You can remove one hdd from the mirror and read the data in another computer.

RAID1 is NOT used for DR, it's for reliability: your server will continue to run even when one of your hdd fails.

As an added benefit, you'll have much faster reads (since the system can read from 2 different hdds at the same time).

HTH,
Dan
0
 
Alex Green3rd Line Server SupportCommented:
The increase in read speeds is marginal and that would only be on a hardware based raid controller, software based is still going to be horribly slow.
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
Software based RAID 1 is not going to be slower than single disk reads.
The penalty you're referring to is on writes.
Here's an article from someone who took the time to test: http://kmwoley.com/blog/?p=429
0
 
Alex Green3rd Line Server SupportCommented:
Sorry but

http://kmwoley.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/image-thumb.png

and

http://kmwoley.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/image-thumb2.png

They both show that the raid is slower on writes and MARGINALLY faster on reads.
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
I said: Software based RAID 1 is not going to be slower than single disk reads.
you said:  the raid is [...] MARGINALLY faster on reads.

I said: The penalty you're referring to is on writes.
you said:  the raid is slower on writes

So, we're arguing on... ?
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
Anyway, to keep the conversation on topic with the OP, on servers where I have no budget for a HW Raid card, I always resort to software RAID 1, to help the server's reliability.

HTH,
Dan
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

Network Scalability - Handle Complex Environments

Monitor your entire network from a single platform. Free 30 Day Trial Now!

  • 5
  • 4
  • 2
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now