Tracing origins of an email - Which country was email sent from? Email headers.

Hi,

In a UK based legal case we have a situation where an email sender claims an email was sent from a certain country (let’s say Vietnam) however the actual email address is a Hotmail.co.uk

So the person claims the email was sent from Vietnam, using Hotmail.co.uk email address. We highly suspect the account was created as a fraudulent account and the actual email originated from the UK.

I will be analysing the headers of the email (Which I can’t paste here for legal reasons) but I wanted to know the best approach proving with  the best certainty which country the email was sent from. I believe the header should contain the IP address of the sending computer.

Thanks in advance.
afflik1923Asked:
Who is Participating?
 
Jeff PerryConnect With a Mentor Windows AdministratorCommented:
If the email was sent from an online hosted email service such as Hotmail then the headers won't help you.
0
 
afflik1923Author Commented:
I was hoping that it would stamp it with an IP that the browser was in, but I guess not?
Is there anything else that could be done.
0
 
Jeff PerryConnect With a Mentor Windows AdministratorCommented:
Yes and No.

You are correct that the header will contain an IP.

That IP may or may not be of any use.

Email headers can be completely falsified. IP addresses can be spoofed.

Hopefully you have a criminal that is not that bright and accessed the account from his home pc and signed up to the fraudulent account with his/her real name and address, but I doubt it.
0
Cloud Class® Course: Ruby Fundamentals

This course will introduce you to Ruby, as well as teach you about classes, methods, variables, data structures, loops, enumerable methods, and finishing touches.

 
afflik1923Author Commented:
The fraudster is trying to create evidence by saying that correspondence occurred between parties. however we think he created a new email hotmail account and faked this conversation.
We don't think they would be technical enough to fake headers or any kind of spoofing.

The hope we have is that the email was meant to be sent from a person based in another country (South Korea in fact). The potential fraudster is based in the UK, so if we could prove the emails were sent from the UK and not from South Korea, that would be good evidence that they were not actually sent by the person who is supposed to have sent them.

however, looking at the headers so far, the originating server seems to be a hotmail one based in California.

That would likely support the case that we will not be able to prove anything.

Let me know your thoughts.
Thanks again.
0
 
Jeff PerryConnect With a Mentor Windows AdministratorCommented:
My thoughts from a purely technical standpoint...

Unless you witness the person log onto a site and perform an act, or can prove a person not only "owns" an account but also that no one else can access it, it is nearly impossible to prove anything.

I hope you can find some way to prove the wrong.
0
 
afflik1923Author Commented:
Probably not, but even circumstantial evidence will be enough to help the case, if it were say, "in most cases it would mean X".
This would be helpful if we can even get to this level.
I've taken the liberty of creating another thread for this where I ask specific questions about South Korea.
http://www.experts-exchange.com/Networking/Protocols/Email/Q_28372773.html

Not expecting miracles, but at least this question is more focused.
Thanks so far for input on this matter.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.