printf can not be a macro defined in terms of fprintf ?

Please explain following sentence from 'C' language book:

"Note, though, that unlike getchar and fgetc, printf can not be a macro defined in terms of fprintf, because macros can not have a variable number of arguments."

Please provide example of how there will be variable number of arguments if printf is a macro defined in terms of fprintf ?
LVL 1
naseeamAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
jkrConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Well, you can create 'getchar()' as a macro from 'fgetc()' like

#define getchar fgetc(stdin)

Open in new window


The same or something similar is isn't possible because 'printf()' takes a variable number of 0 up to n arguments, which cannot be taken care of with a macro, since the latter always takes a defined number of arguments (with the notable exception of gcc, but that's a non-standard compiler extendion).
0
 
SStoryCommented:
printf can have variable number of args.

printf("Good morning, %s, did you know that %d + %d = %d?",name,5,5,10);
printf("Good morning, %s",name);

Here printf has 4 args (5 including the string) in the first, and 1 or 2 in the second. It is saying you can't do this in the macro because it won't allow variable args..I think.
0
 
naseeamAuthor Commented:
Please provide example of printf being a macro defined in terms of fprintf.  Then, explain why it can't be done.
0
 
SStoryConnect With a Mentor Commented:
#define dontwork fprintf(stdin,txt)

It won't work because fprintf can take tons of args based on the format string.  For every %d or %s etc in the string there must be a ,arg1,arg2...,argn

I don not know how much better anyone can explain this.  The above macro expects a single text string with no variables.  How many would you make?  You can not know.  Normally functions like that have an argv array of items or something and maybe the count argc...
0
 
naseeamAuthor Commented:
Great explanation with great examples.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.