Cannot ping ASA 5505 INSIDE INTERFACE across VPN.

Hello,

I cannot ping one of our remote offices ASA 5505's across the site-to-site VPN tunnel.  I've compared the configs of our offices and they do not look any different, so I do not know what I'm missing.

Site 1 cannot ping the inside interface of site 2, however site 2 can ping the inside interface of site 1.

ICMP traffic is being allowed through the firewall and ICMP is enabled in the global policy settings to be inspected.  

Quick note, I can ping site 2's inside interface from a system within site 2, I just can't do it across the VPN.

I'm working via ASDM, so any help fixing this via ASDM would be greatly appreciated.
CKilmer1975Asked:
Who is Participating?
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
Upgrade your firmware to the latest (or at least 8.4.2) and then enter this at the end of your NAT configuration for the tunnel:

no-proxy-arp route-lookup

MO/BB
0
 
Steven CarnahanNetwork ManagerCommented:
Are you getting unreachable or time out?

Unreachable would mean the issue is probably at Site 1 (the originator of the failing ping)
Time Out would mean the issue is probably at Site 2 (the responder of the failing ping)
0
 
CKilmer1975Author Commented:
I'm getting 'Request timed out."
0
Live Q & A: Securing Your Wi-Fi for Summer Travel

Traveling this summer? Join us on June 18, 2018 for a live stream to learn about the importance of Wi-Fi security and 3 easy measures you can start taking immediately to protect your private data while using public Wi-Fi. Follow us today to learn more!

 
Steven CarnahanNetwork ManagerCommented:
Okay, that means that the ping is probably getting from Site 1 to Site 2 but Site 2 is unable or refusing to send a response.

I would start by looking at the ACL's on Site 2 for an implicit deny.
0
 
CKilmer1975Author Commented:
I've attached a screenshot of my ACL.  There are no implicit deny's for ICMP traffic.
ACL.png
0
 
Steven CarnahanNetwork ManagerCommented:
How about Device Management
0
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
Which firmware version are you using?

Also can you post your NAT statements?


-BB
0
 
CKilmer1975Author Commented:
Hi,

@ pony10us, I have nothing listed on that ICMP screen.

ASA : 8.2(5)
ASDM: 6.4(5)

I have attached my NAT info.

NAT info
0
 
CKilmer1975Author Commented:
We do not have a service agreement with Cisco, so I do not have the ability to download firmware from their site.  Is there another way to procure it?
0
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
No legal ways that I know of. The goal is basically to turn proxy arp off on your tunnel NAT configuration.

MO
0
 
CKilmer1975Author Commented:
Ahh, and I suppose there's no way to do it in my current firmware?
0
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
I don't believe so. Sorry about that. Support contract on a 5505 for 8x5 NBD is pretty reasonable. I believe it's only $100. Maybe $150 for the upgraded 24x7, 4 hour hardware replacement warranty. Either one will give you access to Cisco.com so you can download the latest system and asdm software.

MO
0
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
I believe the above costs are for the 50 User licensed 5505. If this is a 10 User licensed 5505 it's even cheaper for SMARTnet.

MO
0
 
Steven CarnahanNetwork ManagerCommented:
I have a 5505 with:

ASA 8.2(2)4
ASDM 7.0(2)

Arp Proxy settings
0
 
CKilmer1975Author Commented:
Thanks for pointing that out pony10us.  Here is my screen:

proxyarp

Will unchecking something here in anyway help?
0
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
Would advise against that. Those are proxy arp settings on physical interfaces which you most likely need intact. We're talking about turning the proxy arp off specially on the tunnel NAT.

MO
0
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
Here's a good read on how proxy arp works on an ASA: http://www.packetu.com/2011/11/07/the-asas-arp-behavior/

I would advise against turning it off globally on an interface. Since the issue is with how proxy-arp works across a VPN tunnel then you only need the ability to turn off proxy-arp on the NAT (or no NAT, technically) associated with the VPN tunnel.

MO
0
 
CKilmer1975Author Commented:
Thanks for the info MO, I'll read up on it.  I'm still trying to figure out how to purchase a service contract.  Cisco's site redirects me to resellers, but the reseller sites aren't listing cisco service contracts so I'm emailing sales to get some answers.
0
 
Michael OrtegaSales & Systems EngineerCommented:
Get one through CDW. That's probably the easiest.

MO
0
 
Steven CarnahanNetwork ManagerCommented:
mgortega:

I see what you are getting at now.  Makes sense.  Here is another good article:  http://www.fir3net.com/Cisco-ASA/cisco-asa-proxy-arp-gotcha.html
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.