Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 612
  • Last Modified:

Vlan Question

Hello
I am trying to establish a Vlan between two switches
getting a little confused between tagged and untagged port assignments
both switches are HP Procurve switches

I switch a is connected on port 39 to switch 2 on port 24?
i have the VLAN id of 58 setup on both switches?
 when i connect the switches i am unable to pass traffic across ( unable to ping a device on switch 2 from switch 1

I am trying to get the devices on switch 2  VLAN 58 to be able to access the internet via our firewall also.
any ideas?
0
schuitkds
Asked:
schuitkds
  • 2
  • 2
1 Solution
 
Lee IngallsDirector of IT/TS, Quality and FinanceCommented:
Here is a screenshot of my Port Based VLAN's on an HP Procurve. Take a look at the Default VLAN, ENG VLAN and ISCSI VLAN to see how I Tagged, Forbade and Untagged specific ports depending on where they are used.

Picture is worth a 1000 words.

Default VLAN is for general usage
Eng is a specific for Design Engineers - basically the same as the Default only segmented from the default traffic and ISCSI.
ISCSI is for my storage array.
HP-ProCurve-Port-Tagging.pdf
0
 
schuitkdsAuthor Commented:
thank you so please clear up what tagged and untagged means in the HP world?
in my scenario of trying to create a vlan on and between two switches
which ports need to be tagged and which ports need to be untagged?
do the ports that connect the switches together on each device need to be tagged?
0
 
Lee IngallsDirector of IT/TS, Quality and FinanceCommented:
Here's a decent copy-paste from HP...

Per-Port VLAN Configuration Options
Parameter Effect on Port Participation in Designated VLAN

**Tagged: Allows the port to join multiple VLANs.

**Untagged: Allows VLAN connection to a device that is configured for an untagged VLAN instead of a tagged VLAN. A port can be an untagged member of only one port-based VLAN.

**Forbid: Prevents the port from joining the VLAN, even if GVRP is enabled on the switch.
Reference: http://h30499.www3.hp.com/t5/Switches-Hubs-Modems-Legacy-ITRC/Difference-between-VLAN-Tagged-and-Untagged/td-p/3836359#.Uyn25fldVc8

My example...
VLAN 1 Default VLAN no ports are tagged and ports 9-12 are forbidden. So no default vlan traffic is permitted all ports not forbidden. The untagged ports are open and available to any traffic.

VLAN 1 ID 20 ENG is a subset of the Default VLAN where I've tagged ports 4-5 and 13-14, which were untagged and not forbidden in the Default VLAN. Just for the Engineers to are working with very large design assemblies concurrently so I'm trying to isolate their traffic between their workstations and the storage array which is ID 30 ISCSI

VLAN 1 ID 30 ISCSI ports tagged 4-5 13-14 27, 33 and the Forbidden Ports the ones from the default vlan. This connects the storage array on a dedicated 10GB per port Switch in a different subnet to the servers. All ISCSI traffic is on a separate subnet who's traffic in VLAN'd at the switch. ENG has subset of Defaul VLAN to isolate it's traffic and provide a less conjested path to the storage array and the default vlan is general network for workstations that are gateway'd to the internet firewall/router.
0
 
schuitkdsAuthor Commented:
so in my scenario basically all ports untagged on the default vlan  on switch A except port 39 which i change to tagged?
switch B port 24 i switch to Tagged?
if i want access to all devices/ports on switch B do i flag all the ports as tagged?

scenario i desire is any device attached to switch A  is able to connect or use any device on switch b

in your scenario about is a device attached to port #2 Vlan1 able to access the device/network on port 4 in Vlan20
0
 
Don JohnstonInstructorCommented:
Here's the quick and easy approach:

Do you have a link that needs to carry more than one VLAN? If so, the port connected to that link needs to tag the frames so that the recipient will know which VLAN a frame belongs to.

If the link is only carrying one VLAN, then the frames do not need to be tagged. Hence, "untagged".
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

Improve Your Query Performance Tuning

In this FREE six-day email course, you'll learn from Janis Griffin, Database Performance Evangelist. She'll teach 12 steps that you can use to optimize your queries as much as possible and see measurable results in your work. Get started today!

  • 2
  • 2
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now