Samsung galaxy Y external speaker

Hello,
my young grandson made an external speaker to connect to his Galaxy, and it works, but the sound is barely audible.
i suspect the speaker does not have the correct impedance.
Anybody knows what speaker impedance is needed?

***i mean a direct wired  external speaker, not Bluetooth or wireless
LVL 93
nobusAsked:
Who is Participating?

Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up

x
 
Tej Pratap Shukla ~DexterConnect With a Mentor Server AdministratorCommented:
You can accept multiple answers for good suggestions and provide average remarks :)
0
 
Tej Pratap Shukla ~DexterConnect With a Mentor Server AdministratorCommented:
Hey there

Well for common speakers/loud speakers we normally use low impedance of 8 O to 16 O.So that audio transmission occurs without using high voltage.My personal opinion is to attach an amplifier to increase sound .
Feel free to ask for further queries.

Thanks
~Dex
0
 
Dan CraciunConnect With a Mentor IT ConsultantCommented:
I bought these for my daughter's PC (actually I bought them for me but did not like 'em and got 2 pairs of Solo 7c's instead :).

She connects her PC, phone, mp3 player to them and the volume is OK.

HTH,
Dan
0
Worried about phishing attacks?

90% of attacks start with a phish. It’s critical that IT admins and MSSPs have the right security in place to protect their end users from these phishing attacks. Check out our latest feature brief for tips and tricks to keep your employees off a hackers line!

 
nobusAuthor Commented:
Dexter 1 Dan, thank you for participating.
the problem is, that i think the 4 or 8 or 16 ohm sopeaker just is not the correct impedance, i suspect it could be 800 ohms.
 i googled for specs - but samsung does not want to tell me...  :=((
and it is a school project, so buying amplifiers won't get points...
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
My daughter's phone is a Galaxy Y (the model from 2013) and it works with those speakers.
I don't think your problem is the ohms, is that your speakers don't have a built-in amplifier that's strong enough.
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
Dan, i don't believe that to be correct, since the output on the phone is much less then too
that's why i believe it's not the correct impedance
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
OK, let's clarify something: are you talking about passive or active speakers?

On passive speakers, yes, the impedance is important, but you would never connect a phone to them, you need an amplifier first. And the only 800 ohm speakers I've seen were some very old (50+ years) that I've seen in a museum.

On all active speakers (meaning self powered speakers with volume control) I've seen, no one talked about impedance.
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
Dan - sorry , but i thought that was clear , since i posted "my young grandson made an external speaker to connect to his Galaxy, and it works, but the sound is barely audible."
if it were amplified, there would be no question of "barely audible"

as for what you say here "you would never connect a phone to them, you need an amplifier first."  that is NOT true, it works on several other phones in his class, and every class makes the baffles with the small speaker; it only does not work on his phone - or maybe on others of that type

So  - the question has nothing to do with "active speakers"
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
OK, if the speakers work with the rest of the phones, this means they are active speakers, and the only logical explanation is that whatever your grandson is trying to play has a very low volume.

You're sure the phone's volume is at max? On the left side of the phone there are the volume keys and it's very easy to accidentally lower the volume.
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
no Dan they're NOT active speakers; they are PASSIVE ones
and the volume is maxed
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
Seems we have a bit of a vocabulary problem.

You cannot connect a phone to a passive speaker. Or you can, but nothing will happen. They absolutely need and amplifier that will also power them. You can easily identify them by the fact that they don't require a power plug.

Active speakers need power to function. That is why they are also called powered speakers. They also have in-built amplifier, which in turn allows the user to plug phones or other audio sources directly into them.

See here and here.
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
Dan there is not  problem; but you simply don't want to accept what i say.
i know what i'm talking about, having a degree in electronics, and being a hifi-fan for years in the turning table and tape recorder era.
i have build amplifiers myself, and designed their schematics - with tubes!
don't explain to me whatr the difference are; i know them - and the question has NOTHING to do with active speakers

the only problem i have is that i can't find any data on the sound output specs of the phone, otherwise, i wouldnot have asked this Q
0
 
Dan CraciunIT ConsultantCommented:
OK, I'm sorry for barging in. I don't have a degree in electronics and did not build speakers.

Just worked for a while in a TV station and picked up little somethings.

Since the phone's audio output is designed for headphones, I don't think it's different from the other phones (or it would need special headphones - and it does not).

If it works for others, and the volume is at max, and you can hear the sound using headphones, the only things that make sense for the low volume are:
1. a bad jack connector.
2. you have a mono speaker, a stereo source with different channels, one of which is very low and the speaker is picking up that channel.
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
how about some data on the galaxy sound output?
that would help me out?
0
 
Tej Pratap Shukla ~DexterServer AdministratorCommented:
Hey nobus
Sorry for the late reply . Well 800 ohms is a lot of impedance , well i researched and found statistics of common smartphone/i phone impedance.

If you really want to max out audio output try increasing the impedance gradually and reach satisfactory audio level.One more thing increasing impedance would detoriate the sound quality , you'll hear screechy sound.

Thanks
~Dex
audioimpedance.png
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
Dexter, i don't know if it is actually 800  or anything else; i just assume the normal low impedance of 4 or 8 ohm is not correct in this case.
in any case, the list you posted shows that not all use the same low impedance
unfortunately, i could not find the galaxy Y there
can you tell me where you found this info - or how?
0
 
Tej Pratap Shukla ~DexterServer AdministratorCommented:
See galaxy Y's output would be dependent on the battery voltage as it has 1200 mAh Li ion battery and galaxy s3 has 2100 mAh battery .So definitely galaxy y has lower impedance .
Well 8-16 ohms is recommended for loudspeakers you can google it too and from there only, I found that information.

~Dex
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
well - i must say i never heard that the output impedance was dependent on the battery (but who knows??)
if anybody has somethign to add - please do!
0
 
Tej Pratap Shukla ~DexterServer AdministratorCommented:
Well i am just a learner here, apologies for any incorrect information. Btw you can check out http://labgruppen.com/media/downloads/product/C_TB_design_power_amps_v2.pdf to look for an ideal speaker impedance

Thanks
~Dex
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
DEXTER - that's all fine, but i need the data to start from
anybody has the data on the sound output ??
0
 
Tej Pratap Shukla ~DexterServer AdministratorCommented:
Asked an expert right now and confirmed your answer.Yes  you were right 15 ohms is too small output impedance as it is meant for headfone mode .As soon as you select the option for an external speaker the impedance is increased around ~300 ohms . So go for 300 ohms impedance .
"Kindly ignore the comment if you find it incorrect or unhelpful"
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
i don't know how to close this Q.
it seems unresolved, ; but some ideas were not bad
what do you guys think?
0
 
nobusAuthor Commented:
i know that - the problem is what to consider as good
but i'll just split for both
0
 
Tej Pratap Shukla ~DexterServer AdministratorCommented:
Thanks :)
~Dex
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.