Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of monorail1
monorail1Flag for United States of America

asked on

arpwatch - constant flip flop with Apple TV3, how to disable flip flop

I've recently set up arpwatch with notifications.  It's working perfectly however every few minutes my apple TV keeps flip flopping MAC addresses.  The apple tv is wired into the network (ethernet) therefore wifi should be disabled.  Also to add, my internal Wifi has a hidden SSID as well as MAC filter and the MAC of the Apple TV isn't permitted so there's no way for it to get on the wifi.  

I have a second Apple TV that's only on wifi and doesn't flip flop.

The question in this post is how to disable flip flop entirely or for a specific device IP or set of MAC addresses.  

Thanks,
Avatar of gheist
gheist
Flag of Belgium image

Main purpose of arpwatch is to detect IP address conflicts.
Now it did.
What is the other device conflicting with your macintosh?
If you unplug the AppleTV ethernet and allow its MAC address on the wireless network, does it successfully connect without further intervention? If so, then it has the password for that SSID stored, and it may indeed make an association to the wireless network, even though your system denies it access, it still makes it into the MAC table.
If that's the case, best way is to reset the AppleTV to defaults (in the menus) and set it up again with no knowledge of the wireless network. If you'd rather not lose all your settings, then just set up a home router temporarily with some network name you'll never see around, connect the AppleTV to it, and it should then lose the other stored SSID credentials (this is not certain to work, because there is some evidence newer firmware can store multiple SSIDs). If that doesn't work, try the same as above, but set up the temporary router with the same SSID you use but a different password. Connect to it, that should overwrite the stored password.

Again, resetting to factory defaults the best route.  Good luck--
Avatar of monorail1

ASKER

@ Gheist - no, there are no IP conflicts just the same device with the same IP (x.x.x.106) showing two different MAC addresses.  All static IP devices are outside of my DHCP range.

@ Schaps - The ATV in question was never added to Wifi but I've done a reset nevertheless, no joy.  Good idea though and I appreciate the suggestion.

I will likely close this question with the solution being an email rule filtering out the keyword of "flip flop".  I was more curious in an arpwatch-based solution though if at all possible.
But different MAC addresses should be getting different IPs.
Can you disable one of interfaces and set it to dhcp again?
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of schaps
schaps
Flag of United States of America image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
@schaps - still didn't fix it but as you provided the most (and helpful) info, you'll get the points.  Cheers,
Ultimately I found a workaround so this didn't resolve the issue but wanted to award the points nonetheless.