Want to protect your cyber security and still get fast solutions? Ask a secure question today.Go Premium

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 450
  • Last Modified:

Dell X8700-1257BLK - Upgrading memory to 32Gig and Quality of memory manufacturer

Two questions:
Will upgrading my memory to 32Gig from 8Gig improve performance.  (or is 16Gig enough?)  I'm doing video and audio editing.
Does the manufacturer of memory matter?  I read in some gaming mags that the maker of memory DOES matter.  

I don't mind paying extra money for more memory or a better manufacturer but I don't want to throw money.
I have a Dell X8700-1257BLK
I have Windows 7 64 Bit home edition.
I currently have two 4 gig modules:
2Rx8  PC3 12800U   11-12-B1  SK Hynix
0
brothertruffle880
Asked:
brothertruffle880
4 Solutions
 
Michael-BestCommented:
"Will upgrading my memory to 32Gig from 8Gig improve performance"
Yes..

"is 16Gig enough?)"

That will depend on the resolution and data size you wish to edit.

"Does the manufacturer of memory matter?"

Not really as competition has forced all manufactures to follow the same standards ( RMA of faulty products is standard policy for all brands.
Avoid Chinese products.
0
 
aadihCommented:
16 Gig is enough; 32 Gig would be nice. Memory brand doesn't matter much as Michael-Best said above.

CPU speed is equally important for video editing. So is the rendering engine.
0
 
rindiCommented:
Whether performance will improve is hard to say, but probably it won't, or not by much. It mainly depends on how much RAM is used currently, and whether your software can really utilize it all. If in your current configuration not all RAM is being used, more won't help. If all the RAM is being used, adding more may help.

With video editing it may help more to use SSD's or RAID 0, as usually the disk speed is the bottleneck.
0
 
Gary CaseRetiredCommented:
"... Will upgrading my memory to 32Gig from 8Gig improve performance. " ==>  Yes, increasing the buffering space for audio and video files will provide additional "headroom" for your editing programs.

"... is 16Gig enough? "  ==>  Also Yes ... and in fact, limiting yourself to 16GB will likely IMPROVE both performance and reliability !!   (more in a moment)

"...  Does the manufacturer of memory matter? " ==>  Buying modules that support the max speed your system supports (1600MHz) and have relatively low latency will have far more impact than who makes them ... but it's still a good idea to buy from a quality manufacturer (Crucial, Kingston, Corsair, etc.).   And it's best to use modules that run at the standard DDR3 voltage (1.5v).

For your system, I'd buy a pair of DDR3-1600 8GB modules.     These would both be good choices:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820148545
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820239291

The Crucial Ballistix has slightly lower CAS latency (9 vs. 11), which means it's marginally faster; but both are excellent choices.    I HAVE seen a few systems that have issues with Ballistix series modules ... but the only way to know for sure is try them.    The conservative choice is the Kingston set.

Edit:  I forgot to add this:   The reason I noted that 16GB is what I'd recommend is simple:   With unbuffered memory modules, the reliability of the memory subsystem is notably higher if you only install two modules.    Installing 4 modules causes a significantly higher bus loading, and severely degrades the waveform of the signaling on the memory bus due to the capacitive effects of the memory.    While it SHOULD work okay; many system BIOS's will automatically reduce the clock speed; increase the latency; or both to work with 4 modules.    And sometimes you have to "tweak" these settings yourself, or even bump up the voltage a small % to help offset the degraded waveform.

Bottom line:  I NEVER install more than 2 modules on systems that use unbuffered memory unless they support ECC modules (so single-bit errors are automatically corrected).

So I'd just put in a pair of 8GB modules, and if you want a further performance gain, upgrade your disk to an SSD.   As rindi noted above, moving to an SSD is likely to provide a far greater improvement in the "feel" of the system than going beyond 16GB of RAM.
0

Featured Post

Industry Leaders: We Want Your Opinion!

We value your feedback.

Take our survey and automatically be enter to win anyone of the following:
Yeti Cooler, Amazon eGift Card, and Movie eGift Card!

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now