Why can't my router ping another router across a layer 3 switch?

I have a strange issue I can not understand - basically I have the following setup:

Router1(172.16.10.254) ---- Layer 2 Switch ---- Layer 2 Switch ---- Router2(172.16.10.1)
PC1(172.16.10.222)---- Layer 2 Switch ---- Layer 2 Switch ---- Router2(172.16.10.1)

I can successfully ping from PC1 to Router2, but unable to ping from Router1 to Router2. I am no expert on networks/switches, but thought it might have something to do with port settings.

Any thoughts?

Router1 is a basic router (Linksys X1000).
LVL 6
FlippAsked:
Who is Participating?

[Webinar] Streamline your web hosting managementRegister Today

x
 
FlippConnect With a Mentor Author Commented:
News just in ..... port misconfiguration ..... 3rd party had changed port mode to trunking and needed to be access.

:-z
0
 
wakatashiCommented:
Suggest checking that the subnet mask is set correctly on the PC and the two routers.
0
 
FlippAuthor Commented:
255.255.255.0 is set on PC, two routers.

It is only traffic between Router1 and Router2 which leaves Switch1 to Switch2 that has an issue.

Was thinking that we should try and inspect traffic for some type of vlan tagging but never performed this and dont really know what I am looking for.
0
Will You Be GDPR Compliant by 5/28/2018?

GDPR? That's a regulation for the European Union. But, if you collect data from customers or employees within the EU, then you need to know about GDPR and make sure your organization is compliant by May 2018. Check out our preparation checklist to make sure you're on track today!

 
FlippAuthor Commented:
Traffic between PCs and both routers are fine ..... this is giving me a headache :)
0
 
wakatashiCommented:
How are you doing the ping from Router1?  Are you telnetting/ssh-ing into a command-line interface?
0
 
R_EdwardsCommented:
I am trying to figure out exactally how you have the connections from router 1 --> switch--> switch --> router 2, from PC 1 can you ping both routers?  have you looked @ the firewalls on the router?  are there ACL's on the switches, or any routes?

thanks
-=Richard
0
 
wakatashiCommented:
...and are the switches layer 2 or layer 3?

 (the diagram says layer 2, but the subject line of the question says layer 3)
0
 
FlippAuthor Commented:
Sorry for the confusion on layer 2 v layer 3. In fact one switch is managed by a 3rd party and they only informed me late today it is only a Layer 2.

Let me try and explain the network a bit better with attached.

We have a fairly basic setup with two switches connected, but a 2nd internal router. Strange thing is that other devices like the PC can ping both routers, but the routers can not ping each other.
NetworkDiagram
0
 
wakatashiConnect With a Mentor Commented:
As a temporary test, try unplugging the PC from the Netgear switch, and connect the Cisco router directly into the same port of the Netgear switch that you just unplugged the PC from.  

See if you can ping now.  If you can, it suggests a faulty switch port, or something weird going on with the Juniper switch.  If you can't, we've at least ruled that out.
0
 
FlippAuthor Commented:
Yes we plugged the cisco directly into netgear and everything worked without Juniper. But I need the Juniper as it is our PoE for phone system.
0
 
wakatashiCommented:
Great, so with the reconfiguration of the Juniper switch, is the problem solved?
0
 
FlippAuthor Commented:
Yes
0
 
wakatashiCommented:
Great!
0
 
FlippAuthor Commented:
Thank you for your input ... I really appreciate the support EE provides through the community of experts. In this situation the solution we worked out through troubleshooting outside of EE.
0
All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.