• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 175
  • Last Modified:

Best practices Design Active directory

Hello gents

i have a question I want to redesign an Active directory ? but there is something that I'm not certain of : Actually I have 2 networks : 192.168 . 6. X where there is One domain Controller and A second Network of 192.168.7.X where there is a Second Domain controller  (Domain is the same). I have Servers that are seating in the two domains.

I want to create a domain for the servers only . Is it a recommended practice?  I want to create a VLAN dedicated to servers .  any Impact on Active directory ?

Rgds
0
gazambey
Asked:
gazambey
1 Solution
 
Wilder_AdminCommented:
You are mixing topics. First to make all clear. AD is more or less for authenticating users and computers so easily to say a trustcenter then you have the topic of network. You have to network as a subnetting setup for locations maybe. And you have VLAN is a accessingcontrol for networks.

All are depending on each other but here does it not make sense to create a new domain.

What you can do instead ist to bring the servers in a own subnet / Vlan and clients etc in a different one. This is depending if you have two locations (cities?) and how they are connected. For VLAN you need special hardware and a way to manage them. Its one to setup and one to manage them. I hope i made it more clear???

At the end you need a concept what you want and how you achieve. In both i can help if you need.
0
 
David Johnson, CD, MVPOwnerCommented:
With a VLAN separating clients and servers brings another question .. how does a client access a server?
0
 
gazambeyAuthor Commented:
Hello People

I appreciate your comments. first of all I'm not mixing Subjects . I know that AD is for Authentication . My question is is it a good practice to have a VLAN for Servers and another One for Computers?

And sorry I don't want to create a new domain . I wanted to say a new network.
0
Making Bulk Changes to Active Directory

Watch this video to see how easy it is to make mass changes to Active Directory from an external text file without using complicated scripts.

 
Andy MIT Systems ManagerCommented:
If you have a separate network for the domain controllers the computers would still need access to that network to authenticate/access files/etc.

I think the first question is what are the reasons for separating out the server/computers - unless there's a specific reason to do so I don't see any reason to separate the servers to another network.
0
 
Wilder_AdminCommented:
You are not seperating Servers from clients with vlan the best practise if you can is to group clients with servers. For example your accounting has a own Terminalserver where alle financial Software is installed on. So it would make sense to seperate them from the rest of the network except of the dc.

Thats the way for vlans. What you can do is the subnetting topic to collect all clients in one and the servers in the other. Thats only cosmetic. It can make sense for example when your dhcp scope is getting to small then it would be a good idea to seperate the clients.

Even think about of ipv6 in your internal network? I know its the future and no need yet but if you want to be the first then its time to do.
0
 
Pramod UbheCommented:
recommended practice is that you should have separate vlans for desktops and servers but those should communicate with each other. In AD you can create separate sites based on your subnets/location or map both the subnets to be authenticated within single site.
I think in your current setup you have separate domains which can easily be  done with sites and services or subnets in AD
0
 
Seth SimmonsSr. Systems AdministratorCommented:
i can see separating the networks through vlans like that in a large environment but if it isn't too large i would keep it simple and use one network; perhaps using 192.168.6.0/16 which will give you 512 addresses and will still allow you to separate into the .6 and .7 for servers and clients.  unless they are in different physical locations, i would keep both subnets in the same AD site
0

Featured Post

Creating Active Directory Users from a Text File

If your organization has a need to mass-create AD user accounts, watch this video to see how its done without the need for scripting or other unnecessary complexities.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now