• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 332
  • Last Modified:

Router Recommendations for Terminal Server Access

Hi,
  I have a site where they have a Windows 2008 Terminal Server and a typical Linksys Router (sub $100). On average, there are about remote 10 users who run apps from the Terminal Server and they complain about every 2 weeks that their Terminal Session (Remote Desktop session) gets bogged down or too slow. After power cycling Linksys router, users are generally happy for another 2-3 weeks.

  Is this type of router (Linksys, Dlink, ... etc) unfit for multiple Terminal Server connections?

  These inexpensive home routers have been working fine for the network which is less than 20 PCs so far in my experience but the traffic was all one way - they surf the internet from local workstations and download & browse sites.

 But I have one other customer whose salespeople access their Terminal Server and at that side I installed CISCO 1811 and I never had any complains from outside/remote users nor had to restart the router for over 5 years. Of course, home routers are sub $100 and CISCO1811 was over $1,200 then.

 That said, do I need to get something like CISCO1811 or CISCO Miraki?
 I appreciate your recommendations in advance.
0
sglee
Asked:
sglee
5 Solutions
 
Cliff GaliherCommented:
I am not a fan of consumer routers in a small business. Even without TS, there are issues. They just don't have code optimized for managing multiple simultaneous sonncectikns (incoming or outgoing.)

For basic routing needs, microTik or ubiquiti is good. But for a modest prce different, you can get ti to a UTM (great for a business) and then try level devices are fine for up to 50 users easily. Sonicwall, watchguard, fortinet, even Untangle has appliance versions of their software now. All are pretty good.
0
 
Natty GregIn Theory (IT)Commented:
Cisco router all the way,
0
 
Jeff LewandowskiCommented:
I typically agree that businesses should be using business grade hw/sw.  It may be cost prohibitive, unjustifiable in the eyes of a SMB owner.  In that case, you can look at cloud-based options like http://pertino.com/.  We use Cisco Meraki equipment for our wifi networks.  They are great and super easy to manage.  We have a Cisco 2811 router that has suited our needs with little maintenance for the past seven years.
0
 [eBook] Windows Nano Server

Download this FREE eBook and learn all you need to get started with Windows Nano Server, including deployment options, remote management
and troubleshooting tips and tricks

 
Cliff GaliherCommented:
Ugh. Typing while mobile. To clear up any confusion from my last post...

sonncectikns = connections.    so mangled that autocorrect couldn't figure it out.  And regarding devices like sonicwall, I was speaking of "entry" level. Which got turned into "and then try." So....yeah. Hope that helps.
0
 
sgleeAuthor Commented:
Thanks for thevrecommendations.
I am leaning towards to either Miraki (new and web based graphical user interface with price tag of >$1,000) or Cisco 1811 router (reliable and cheap at Ebay - sun $300). Both requires yearly support subscription from Cisco.
Unless someone tells Miraki is a far better product, I like to buy new Cisco router off Ebay for <$300. The only concern is that it is an old technology perhaps?
0
 
Cliff GaliherCommented:
Meraki is good. While Cisco did buy them fairly recently, both their hardware and software is still their own. No moves have been made to gut/replace them yet. The 1811 is a middle of the road product. I think it is overpriced for what it does in the current market.

I will also strongly caution against eBay. Routers, in particular, are being sold with backdoors installed, just waiting to take advantage of the cheapskate looking to pinch a penny. I have personally been called in to consult on digital forensics issues that have traced back to modified routers purchased from unreliable sources too many times this year for that to be a coincidence. You get what you pay for. Regardless of which option you choose, buy from an authorized reseller.
0
 
sgleeAuthor Commented:
Why is Miraki's range is so wide?
I have seen them priced from several hundreds to a couple of thousands...
0
 
Cliff GaliherCommented:
Most of your UTMs are that way, and Meraki is competing in the UTM space more than the router space. Traffic shaping and application layer security filtering takes optimized code and CPU cycles, so UTMs need to scale up hardware and software-wise more rapidly to support higher user counts. That means the price jumps between models is higher. It isn't just Meraki. All of the UTM vendors have similar pricing structures.
0
 
sgleeAuthor Commented:
That makes sense. Then can you recommend a specific model that will fit the following needs:
1. Port forwarding
2. Up to 15 connections from outsides
3. 10 users on local network for web surfing.
4. Less than 20 devices on local network including 15 PCs, 3 servers, one ip-based printer.
5. Site to site VPN capability with cloud services like Microsoft Azure.
0
 
Cliff GaliherCommented:
Before I recommend equipment for my clients, I always put in a traffic monitor and get a few days worth of data to view trends. Then I know how they use the internet. 20 devices regularly sharing files with dropbox or SharePoint online will need more horsepower than 20 devices that only ever use twitter.

So while you are not a client of mine, I am not in the habit of making recommendations with incomplete information. I could end up recommending a device that can't keep up. Or end up recommending a device far more expensive than you need. I don't risk my reputation on idle speculations.
0
 
sgleeAuthor Commented:
Your point well received.
In fact I read some negative reviews on Meraki on Spiceworks website and I am not sure if Meraki is the best solution.
I will explore more options.

Thanks experts for your recommendations.
0

Featured Post

Concerto Cloud for Software Providers & ISVs

Can Concerto Cloud Services help you focus on evolving your application offerings, while delivering the best cloud experience to your customers? From DevOps to revenue models and customer support, the answer is yes!

Learn how Concerto can help you.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now