DNS Server Replication

Up until last week, we had 2 DNS servers running in 2 different sites.  One on the west coast and the primary on the east coast.  They were both 2003 domain controllers and we extended the schema so that a new 2012 server could be promoted to a domain controller in the east coast as a 2nd DNS server and another 2008 domain controller was promoted in the west coast site so all in all there are currently 4 DNS servers, 2 on each site.  My question is, that all 4 are reporting as authoritative and wanted to know if this is correct given that they are all active directory integrated.  The main or primary DNS server resides in east coast and is 2003 server.  Also, each server is pointing to the primary in east coast as the primary dns server on its nic card settings and the secondary for each is the loopback of  In the event of the primary going down, would the others take over automatically or would i have to point the client machines to the other servers ip address?  Thanks.
Who is Participating?
David Johnson, CD, MVPConnect With a Mentor OwnerCommented:
if any dns server goes down and the others are not  in the list of dns servers then they will be down for all. you could add all dns servers into the dns settings on the nic cards.  Each server having the entries as ;
server 1 east coast
server 1 ip address
server 2 ip address east coast
server 3 ip address west coast
server 4 ip address west coast
and so forth
dankyle67Author Commented:
Just to clarify, the 4 ip addresses of the DNS servers would be entered into the client pc nic cards correct? As for the DNS servers themselves, I have the primary DNS as the DNS server in east coast and the secondary as Is this sufficient or should I add the other 2 DNS servers as well?
footechConnect With a Mentor Commented:
I would configure each DNS server at each site to only refer to itself and the other DNS at the same site in the NIC properties.  I see little to no benefit to adding DNS servers from other sites when you have more than one in a site.  You can configure either the other DNS or itself as the preferred, but I generally recommend configuring the other as preferred and itself as alternate.

And yes, for AD-integrated zones each server will report itself as the SOA.
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.