Batch File Compare numbers issue

I am having issues with a variable compare, and I am just not seeing the resolution.

I have an input file called 'check_out.txt" that looks like this:
<there is an empty line here>
+----------------------+
|REC_PER_SEC           |
+----------------------+
|100.00                     |
+----------------------+

Open in new window


My script is to go to the 5th line, read the total, strip off the spaces and pipe, and then make certain the number is greater than a fixed number.

My code is:
@echo off
set "lineNr=5"
set /a lineNr-=1
for /f "usebackq delims=" %%a in (`more +%lineNr%  c:\temp\check_out.txt`) DO (
  set xxx=%%a
  goto :getnumber
)

:getnumber
set myresults1=%xxx:|=%
set myresults=%myresults1: =%
echo %myresults%
  goto :comparenumber
  
:comparenumber
if "%myresults%" GTR "40.00" (
  echo "Above threadhold of 40.00 records per second. All is good"
  goto :GOODEND
) else (
  echo "Below threshold of 40.00 records per second. Please investigate"
  echo "Number of Records per second: %myresults%"
  goto :BADEND
)

:GOODEND
REM del c:\imd_check\imd_check_out.txt
exit /B 0

:BADEND
REM del c:\imd_check\imd_check_out.txt
exit /B 99

Open in new window


No matter how I run this---it always returns:

100.00
"Below threshold of 40.00 records per second. Please investigate"
"Number of Records per second: 100.00"

What am I missing?
PAH_in_MIAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
oBdAConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Here's an adjusted version that simply ignores everything after the decimal point (if you really need it, please tell us the expected maximum value for the records per second); note that Batch can only calculate with integers from -2147483648 to 2147483647.
@echo off
set CheckOutFile=C:\temp\check_out.txt
set Threshold=40
set lineNr=5
set /a Skip = lineNr - 1
for /f "skip=%Skip% delims=|. " %%a in ('type "%CheckOutFile%"') do (
  set Rec_Per_Sec=%%a
  goto :CompareNumber
)

:CompareNumber
if %Rec_Per_Sec% GTR %Threshold% (
  echo Above threshold of %Threshold%.00 records per second. All is good.
  goto :GOODEND
) else (
  echo Below threshold of %Threshold%.00 records per second. Please investigate.
  echo Number of Records per second: %Rec_Per_Sec%.00
  goto :BADEND
)

:GOODEND
REM del "%CheckOutFile%"
exit /B 0

:BADEND
REM del "%CheckOutFile%"
exit /B 99

Open in new window

Note that for the "below" message to be technically correct, you'd need to use GEQ instead of GTR in the comparison.

Edit: corrected test threshold of 110 back to 40.
0
 
NVITCommented:
You can't have a decimal point. Also, remove the quotes. i.e. 100 gtr 40
0
 
PAH_in_MIAuthor Commented:
Thanks for the solution.  I guess I just assumed decimals were allowed. I am giving you full credit because not only did you state that, but you also provided code to resolve it---and made the remove of spaces a bit cleaner.

Thanks
0
 
oBdACommented:
Well, decimals are basically "allowed", but since the shell finds a non-numeric character, it will do a string comparison instead of a numeric one, and then "100" will indeed be less than "40".
The shell will do a string comparison as well if you enclose the values in quotes.
And the 32bit limit can really lead to unexpected results, because 2147483648 will be treated as -1 ...
Just for fun:
@echo off
call :Test 10 gtr 2
call :Test 10.0 gtr 2
call :Test "10" gtr "2"
call :Test 2147483647 gtr 2147483646
call :Test 2147483648 gtr 2147483647
call :Test "2147483648" gtr "2147483647"
goto :eof

:Test
echo Testing '%*' ...
if %* (echo ... true) else (echo ... false)
goto :eof

Open in new window

0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.