Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up


What do you think about government bailouts now?

Posted on 2015-01-14
Medium Priority
Last Modified: 2015-02-03

What do you think about government bailouts now?


U.S. Declares Bank and Auto Bailouts Over, and Profitable - By JONATHAN WEISMAN - DEC. 19, 2014

the bailouts were assumed to be enormous drains on the federal Treasury. Yet in the end, the Troubled Asset Relief Program and the Detroit bailout yielded $15.35 billion in profit, Treasury officials said Friday.
“The American auto industry is on track for its strongest year since 2005,” Mr. Obama said. “And we’ve created about half a million new jobs in the auto industry alone.”
Question by:SunBow
  • 4

Assisted Solution

by:Monika Bharti
Monika Bharti earned 92 total points
ID: 40550658
hi SunBow,

Whenever there will be recession the politician will rescue the big fishes for the simple reason that they are the driving force of an economy and so much money revolves around them and it is simply not feasible to let them go down.  So the bailout not matter now or in year 2050 will always favor us the big daddies of the economy system and  tax-payer will have to just sit and watch as usual.
LVL 27

Accepted Solution

tliotta earned 108 total points
ID: 40552645
The bailouts benefited far more than just the 'big daddies'.

Many, many elderly, for example, survive through investments in retirement accounts that give interest/dividend income. Many of those hold portions of direct investments in the involved entities. A solid failure of any major Fortune 100 class of corporation would affect stock and bond markets across the board causing widespread losses, so indirect investments would also be hit. (I'm not retired, but my 401k would still suffer.) Direct job losses also affect indirect jobs servicing the workers as consumers.

Other socio-economic interconnections exist, and they all would have far reaching and long lasting consequences.

What I'm more interested in than any 'profit' for the government are the consequences for corporate executives that could be deemed professionally at fault for any causes of corporate need.

IMO, economic collapse is more of a national security issue than terrorist attacks. As such, governmental action is more appropriate for it. To me, "national security" involves threat to the survival of the 'nation'. War with another nation is valid; but terrorist actions are more for police work. I'm fine with using military elements for 'police work' in such cases, but many of the legal structures that have been put in place in the name of "national security" do not logically follow.

That leads off-topic, but it should be meaningful as opinion on the relative importance of the two areas of governmental action.

LVL 24

Author Comment

ID: 40581166
[Abandoned (14 Days)]
The 14th Annual Expert Award Winners

The results are in! Meet the top members of our 2017 Expert Awards. Congratulations to all who qualified!

LVL 24

Author Comment

ID: 40586191
Well, looks like little interest remains in any debating this, so I'll try a hand at responding...

Monika Bharti > politician will rescue the big fishes....

This happens to be close to my observation on tsunami relief - hurry, scurry to rebuild fancy hotels with added perks for politicians wanting to pay visit for photo-op on how much they care about (raising funds) ...

US has also failed to complete promised restorations for numerous internal flood reliefs, while paying well for funerals etc. of big-daddies who died prior to flood.

tliotta > Many, many elderly, for example, survive through investments in retirement accounts

I'd rather disagree on that, where in general, the bankers/Wall St hurt them badly with all those mismanagement shenanigans. I cannot disagree however concerning 'Detroit' (label for US made vehicles, affecting many states), having met many who were provided deep 'employee discounts' for certain company models, and discouraged from driving alternative to work.

While unrestrained Detroit would provide employees > 3 months off per year, and dump on public vehicles they did not want, they themselves cleaned up a lot fearing not only public reaction but government intrusion.

> A solid failure of any major Fortune 100 class of corporation

Sorry, but Wall St remains a nest of gamblers, such that for every winner there be a loser, - and for every loser there be a winner. See also the previous bailout of S&L debacle.

> Other socio-economic interconnections exist,

er, like the 'forgiving' of loans, including certain nations...

>  consequences for corporate executives that could be deemed professionally at fault

If I read that right, I can agree, rather than sending lawbreakers to prison, they were rewarded with humonguous multi-million dollar bonuses for meeting corporate goals.

> IMO, economic collapse is more of a national security issue than terrorist attacks. As such, governmental action is more appropriate for it. To me, "national security"

While I am tempted to agree, one must remember results of so many foreclosures anyway, including of people who could have held on but for the confusing paperwork.

Most of the panic (re:Wall St) was generated by Bush in his last few days of providing rewards, sounding drums of fear.

For every loser there is a winner - the winners should not have to yield their winnings to the bunglers who lost to them. Nor should the poor have to reward the rich who have failed. If you let them fail, it is the less qualified executives that are excised, the better executives who retain/gain position.

>  I'm fine with using military elements for 'police work'

I'd be tempted to agree, but for the vastness of abuse, and the police using funerals to protest spending on video cameras.

> That leads off-topic

Well, I'll revert to own personal disappointment in accounting for benefits derived from bailouts, getting as suspicious about those details as the details embedded in budget to restore to Bankers their desired form of non-regulation.

In summation - I'm taking a time-out to rethink, where I am not sure about having a conclusion here for closure. Other than my:

Those who choose to go 'insured' should not be required to be treated as the insurance provider of those who prefer to risk being uninsured to have opportunity for greater personal gain.

Those who lose, should pay the price, and not expect to be saved out of pity. Nowadays the bigshots get to not only keep their private planes, they get to upgrade them when caught abusing others.
LVL 24

Author Comment

ID: 40586356
The people need a government that can act to provide for the national interest. How well that is done, or not done, remains for the people to evaluate themselves.

As for original question, the (two) experts appear to have left this as either a tie or as something in nature of having to live with, liked or not.

There does not seem to be much of a change in personal opinion over time.


In closing ... experts showing about equal value, concerning target, seems appropriate to award the word-count as 'best', with few pts (~5) for that. That's, <um> 27,23.

LVL 24

Author Comment

ID: 40586498
+++ Noticed +++

Monika Bharti
Member Since:   2015-01-13
Points:                          14,248
Points This Month:       4,092


¤ Hi Monika, a hearty welcome to the Politics (& 'other') TA
   This should place you in top ten for the TA YTD
   Do feel free to contribute, and contribute often.
  [does that sound like some political quotation?]

and a belated welcome to Experts-Exchange,

you appear to already be doing well already on points, in less than a month being on a roll to sustaining free membership (balancing tech TAs)

***  Good  Fortune  ***

Featured Post

Free Tool: SSL Checker

Scans your site and returns information about your SSL implementation and certificate. Helpful for debugging and validating your SSL configuration.

One of a set of tools we are providing to everyone as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Learn more about the importance of email disclaimers with our top 10 email disclaimer DOs and DON’Ts.
Get an idea of what you should include in an email disclaimer with these Top 5 email disclaimer tips.
Watch the video to know how one can repair corrupt Exchange OST file effortlessly and convert OST emails to MS Outlook PST file format by using Kernel for OST to PST converter tool. It can convert OST to MSG, MBOX, EML to access them. It can migrate…
In the video, one can understand the process of resizing images in single or bulk. Kernel Bulk Image Resizer is an easy to use tool for resizing large number of images. One can add and resize multiple images with this tool in single go. The video sh…

585 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question