• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 203
  • Last Modified:

Switches -- Layer2 vs Layer3

What switches (layer2 or layer3)
do you recommend for the below ?

  ** 10 buildings about 300 feet from each other
  ** 5 people in each building, 50 total people
  ** each desk has one NetworkCord plugged into one
        VOIP phone, which plugs into one desktop PC
  ** internal multi-mode fiber between buildings
  ** budget = would like to have 10 switches under
       $900 each, but am willing to go higher, can be referb
  ** OK with doing VOIP QOS and VLANS, but don't have to
0
finance_teacher
Asked:
finance_teacher
  • 4
  • 3
  • 3
  • +3
11 Solutions
 
ajeabCommented:
layer 2 should be ok.  or basic layer 3 that sold bundle with most cisco switches will be OK. most switches sold with basic L3 which allow vlan/QOS.  you might want to invest in POE switch as the cost is not much different.
0
 
ajeabCommented:
2960g-24 avail on ebay around $300-500 range

or 2960g-8 for around $300 or less.

cisco sfp sx also avail on ebay around  $30 each
0
 
Stephen BerkSenior Network EngineerCommented:
I'd look at the Small Business 200 Series of smart switches from Cisco, the 2960's are overkill and won't have support. You can get a 10-port (8 LAN, 2 WAN) with POE from CDW, new with support for under $400. You just need to add the SFP's for your MM fiber.

Cisco product page: http://goo.gl/G5x4iZ
CDW listing: http://goo.gl/164WYy

EDIT: I don't believe these have IP routing, so you'll still need a router somewhere on your campus for routing between VLANs and for Internet access.
0
SMB Security Just Got a Layer Stronger

WatchGuard acquires Percipient Networks to extend protection to the DNS layer, further increasing the value of Total Security Suite.  Learn more about what this means for you and how you can improve your security with WatchGuard today!

 
Joey YungSenior Network EngineerCommented:
If there can be designed as a physical ring topology, I would recommend each building to have the following layer2 switch package:

WS-C2960CPD-8PT-L
PWR-ADPT
GLC-SX-MM x 2

BTW, you should aware this switch model can provide only around 23W POE power, if you need 5 POE endpoint, that's mean each can only take around 4.5W
0
 
MattCommented:
"I'd look at the Small Business 200 Series of smart switches from Cisco, the 2960's are overkill and won't have support."

What do you mean "won't have support"?
0
 
MattCommented:
Can you tell us how many users are planned in the near future? Just to be on the safe side, so you don't need to buy the same hardware twice...

Do you need POE?
0
 
finance_teacherAuthor Commented:
100 users max
no POE needed
0
 
ajeabCommented:
I think "won't have support" mean if you buy used product, you can't get support from Cisco.  but if you buy it from right reseller, they offer lifetime warranty on what they sell.  some do offer 3rd party phone support at fraction of the cost of smartnet.   I think 2960G (Gig all ports, no POE) or 2960S (Gig all ports + POE) used is good fit. have room to grow.   most switch do not fail.  you can get new switch model but I think it's overprice.  

whatever way you choose,  I do recommend for you to look at the price different between non-POE and POE.  it may not be that much different but it will make your VOIP install easier.

used market for Cisco gear is huge. you won't have problem getting support.

the WS-C2960CPD-8PT-L above does not provide SFP port.  also it's only 10/100.
0
 
Stephen BerkSenior Network EngineerCommented:
Sorry, by "no support" I meant exactly what ajeab stated, which is no Smartnet through Cisco. Hardware support is ubiquitous from 3rd party sellers, but you need Smartnet in many cases to get software updates from Cisco, especially if the switch you buy uses licenses instead of the IOS image to unlock functionality. I use 3rd party sellers for home lab gear, but I wouldn't for my business.

Joey, the switch you mentioned doesn't have POE output for attaching devices, but it can take POE input to power the switch itself. You have to provide it POE or buy the power adapter and cord.
0
 
RhysehCommented:
Does it have to be Cisco? There are a number of competing manufacturers that could give you a brand new 24 port POE switch at that price.

I've been eying off the ubiquiti edgemax switches. Junipers
0
 
finance_teacherAuthor Commented:
It can be anything, I don't need CISCO
0
 
RhysehCommented:
I would get some prices on some PoE ex2200's if I were you. They are a little different on the CLI front but they work beautifully, good feature set and support is usually great. They also have a useful GUI if you want to use it. Talk to a local juniper partner and see what they can do.
0
 
RhysehCommented:
You could also look at the ubiquiti edgemax switches the feature set is nice for the price. Performance won't be as good as the juniper's though.
0
 
ajeabCommented:
ubqt will be hard to get support.  better to go with major mfg.
0
 
MattCommented:
You could try HP ProCurve, 16 port HP V1910-16G JE005A.
0

Featured Post

Free Tool: Port Scanner

Check which ports are open to the outside world. Helps make sure that your firewall rules are working as intended.

One of a set of tools we are providing to everyone as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

  • 4
  • 3
  • 3
  • +3
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now