Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of AJNS
AJNS

asked on

hosted email - ptr and smtp banners

We have found ourselves hosting email for a couple of different companies. I was not a planned thing, one company lost their building and equipment, we merged (sort of) with another company that wanted to retain their domain and a third company had their host go under.

All of a sudden we have four email domains coming into our network. It was all very temporary and now it looks like it may be permanent. Right now each domain has an MX record pointing to our firewall. The firewall forwards the request to our Barracuda 300 and then on to the appropriate mail server.

Right now only our domain has a proper ptr record. The other three are using our extra IP addresses. As well the Barracuda responds with an smtp banner that says barracuda.mydomain.com

When we use the diagnostics tools at mxtoolbox.com it has issues with the ptr record not matching and the smtp banner not matching.

I'm curious what would be the normal smtp banner to display in a hosting environment.

For the ptr records I can easily have them created as each domain is using a single IP address. If we continue to do this we will want to consolidate these onto one or two IP addresses, no need to use them all up. How do you deal with ptr records when more than one domain is using an ip address?

I'm guessing there should not be more than one ptr per IP address.

Do you create a single email domain like catchallemail.mydomain.com and change all the mx records to that? That gives just one ptr record and the barracuda should then sort the email by domain.

Thanks for any info
Avatar of Imtiaz Hasham
Imtiaz Hasham
Flag of United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland image

SMTP Banner - Not the end of the world - leave it as your primary domain.

Don't do anything Catch All

PTR Record -> If it's to different IP addresses, you can assign a PTR record to each - however, again, as long as there is a correct PTR record to the primary domain, I wouldn't care.

The best practice scenarios wouldn't work in your case - but I wouldn't care that much :)
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of Simon Butler (Sembee)
Simon Butler (Sembee)
Flag of United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of AJNS
AJNS

ASKER

Thanks for the info Simon.
Hello????

How was my answer any different to Simon's?