TONER -- One or more cartridges appear to be damaged ?

Any ideas on how to fix the below ONE bad machine ?
  ** Maybe it just has ink residue that for some reason is not detected on the others ?

HP Officejet Pro X476dw -- Machine #1
1.      Insert new BLACK toner
2.      Make 20 copies
3.      Works fine

HP Officejet Pro X476dw -- Machine #2
1.      Insert same BLACK toner
2.      Make 20 copies
3.      Works fine

HP Officejet Pro X476dw -- Machine #3
1.      Insert same BLACK toner
2.      Make 20 copies
3.      Fails with “One or more cartridges appear to be damaged, remove them and replace with new cartridges” message
4.      Insert same BLACK toner into above machine #1 or #2
5.      Make 20 copies
6.      Still works fine in machine #1 or #2, but always fails in machine #3
7.      Insert BLACK toner from nonOEM vendor #2, works fine in machine #3
8.      Test with 5+ other new BLACK toner from nonOEM vendor #1