You know, experts needs a live chat room where we can get together in groups and chat things out. That's how I work best you know....talking it thru with peeps and sorting out the mess. Anyway....
Environ: Server 2008 Domain that I inherited.
The servers, as you all know, use DFS for sysvol replication. That's great.
DFS is also a role you can install for namespaces and folder replication.
To me, the two things are different.
What I inherited is that someone launched the DFS MSC on their PC and connected to the domain controller and added a ton of namespaces there. They didn't install the role, they just connected to the DC and started adding namespaces, on the DC
To me, this is horrible!
I would have installed the DFS role on a file server or something, NOT a DC, and put my namespaces there.
In its current config, there are no tools to manage the DFS with and now, I have the task of upgrading the DC to 2012 R2. I think the added problem of the DFS being on the DC like it is, complicates things.
I'd like some discussion on my thought process, about DFS, where it should be hosted, whether or not it should be on a DC, etc.
What I want to do is spin up servers to host the proper DFS role and leave the new DCs being DCs only and not piggy back off the DFS installed for the sysvol replication.