Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of Ramy Mohsen
Ramy Mohsen

asked on

how to tell link is safe and trusted

I am developing a PHP web application through Yii2 framework that enable the user to enter any link and display it within iframe I need to know

    is it safe for the web application and user to use this feature (iframe) with his own link
    how to avoid risks
    if the user has entered a link how to tell this link is safe and trusted
Avatar of Dave Baldwin
Dave Baldwin
Flag of United States of America image

There isn't any way to tell.  If you display it in an iframe, your server code never sees that content because it gets loaded by the user's browser directly into the iframe.
Avatar of Brittk McGhee
Brittk McGhee

The most excellent proposal I can offer is to browse smart. That means you have to twice check the URL of your,social networking site, and e-mail site before you log in. Its very safe for web application uses this aspect.
Avatar of Ramy Mohsen


if the user has entered a link can I use a service to tell this link is safe and trusted  or not
Avatar of skij
Flag of Canada image

Link to home
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
if the user has entered a link can I use a service to tell this link is safe and trusted  or not
No, you cannot.  Your strategy is risky and dangerous.  It should be avoided.  Here's why.

When you see the link, all you can know is the character string that makes up the URL.  You cannot know what is going to be loaded from that URL.  It can be "safe and trusted" one moment and "toxic and damaging" the next.  You have no control at all.  A client visit to the URL, which is caused by loading in the iframe or browser window, causes your browser to run JavaScript immediately and without warning.  What does the JavaScript contain?  You cannot know what the JavaScript will do to the client machine until the client runs the JavaScript code.

This is part of PHP Security.  There are well-documented standard practices that are necessary to keep users of your web site safe from one another.  You may also want to learn about OWASP and become involved.
Couple of thoughts about MyWOT.
I have no way to evaluate these claims, but "buyer beware."
The only way to accomplish your objective is to use a third-party validation service.  I have used MyWOB for this and it meets my needs nicely.  Of course any popular service will have its haters, including this website!  I am not going to argue with Ray anymore about this, but I will say I have used the MyWOB API for three years with great results.

Here is a working prototype accomplishing the request made in your original post.  If you find that it blocks too many sites, you can lower the value of $sensitivity.

$sensitivity = 95;

if(empty($_POST['url'])) {

<!DOCTYPE html>
<meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge" />


<form action="<?php echo htmlspecialchars($_SERVER["PHP_SELF"], ENT_QUOTES, "utf-8"); ?>" method="post" target="f">
 URL: <input type="text" name="url" />
 <input type="submit" />

 <iframe width="80%" height="200" name="f"></iframe>

else {

$site = $_POST['url'];

$urlinfo = parse_url($site);
if (!isset($urlinfo['host'])) $urlinfo = parse_url('http://' . $site);

$host = preg_replace('/[^a-z0-9\-\.]/i', '', $urlinfo['host']);

$siteReport = json_decode(file_get_contents(''. $host .'/&key=59e026a43597840e5ddefba4d692be8212926801'));

if( !empty($siteReport->{$host}->categories->{'501'}) && $siteReport->{$host}->categories->{'501'} > $sensitivity ) {
 header('Location: ' . $urlinfo['scheme'] . '://' . $host . (empty($urlinfo['path']) ? '' : $urlinfo['path'])  . (empty($urlinfo['query']) ? '' : '?' . $urlinfo['query']), TRUE, 307);
else {
  echo 'Bad Site!'; 



Open in new window