excel learner

asked on

# # of months between two dates

Dear experts,

I need a simple formula which can calculate the number of months between two dates. I have provided a formula which I picked it up from website and I wish to perfect it to:

consider the holiday if the later date is a holiday, then the formula should consider the day after the holiday and then include it as the month

The list of holidays is provided in sheet 'holidays'

Column F has the desired result.

Kindly help.

Thank you

--of-months-between-two-dates.xlsx

I need a simple formula which can calculate the number of months between two dates. I have provided a formula which I picked it up from website and I wish to perfect it to:

consider the holiday if the later date is a holiday, then the formula should consider the day after the holiday and then include it as the month

The list of holidays is provided in sheet 'holidays'

Column F has the desired result.

Kindly help.

Thank you

--of-months-between-two-dates.xlsx

ASKER

Rgonzo, yes it should be 13 and not 12.

Can you please help me understand the logic behind -1 inside the brackets and +1 outside the brackets.

Thank you

Can you please help me understand the logic behind -1 inside the brackets and +1 outside the brackets.

Thank you

we take may 1, 16 to June 2, 16

that makes

a difference of one month between may 1, 16 to June 1, 16

plus 1 Equals 2

that makes

a difference of one month between may 1, 16 to June 1, 16

plus 1 Equals 2

I was trying to take a look but having problems downloading the file.

DATEDIF doesn't take into account holidays.

NETWORKDAYS can take weekends and a list of holidays into account but that gives number of working days rather than months.

Thanks

Rob

DATEDIF doesn't take into account holidays.

NETWORKDAYS can take weekends and a list of holidays into account but that gives number of working days rather than months.

Thanks

Rob

SOLUTION

membership

This solution is only available to members.

To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.

ASKER

ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION

membership

This solution is only available to members.

To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.

ASKER

Rgonzo,

Can you please explain the logic in the formula. I could not understand it.

Thank you,

Can you please explain the logic in the formula. I could not understand it.

Thank you,

I managed to get the file to download eventually before, hence the formulas which I posted.

ASKER

Rob,

Also some questions:

1) What if Start Date is a holiday? Very unlikely

2) What if Finish Date is a holiday and Finish Date +1 is also a holiday? //Then move the date to the next working day but the Month count should still be in the previous month count or in the 1 month count (the floor value for the result)

Also some questions:

1) What if Start Date is a holiday? Very unlikely

2) What if Finish Date is a holiday and Finish Date +1 is also a holiday? //Then move the date to the next working day but the Month count should still be in the previous month count or in the 1 month count (the floor value for the result)

ASKER

Rob,

The values in column C and D are given I cannot amend those dates

The values in column C and D are given I cannot amend those dates

this part

this part

`WORKDAY.INTL(D9,-1,MOD(WEEKDAY(D9)+1,7)+1,Holidays!$A$2:$A$20))`

calculates the first non holiday date before D9 this part

`MOD(WEEKDAY(D9)+1,7)+1`

place the weekend after D9 to not affect the calculation of the non holiday date
ASKER

Rob, a correction, sorry for my wrong comment

Values in Col. B and C are given and I cannot change them

Values in Col D are only shown for this illustration to convey my thought process. In the actual file this field would not exist.

Thank you

Values in Col. B and C are given and I cannot change them

Values in Col D are only shown for this illustration to convey my thought process. In the actual file this field would not exist.

Thank you

ASKER

Rgonzo,

The number of months should be calculated based on values in col. b and C and column D would not exist in the actual file.

Kindly help.

Thank you

The number of months should be calculated based on values in col. b and C and column D would not exist in the actual file.

Kindly help.

Thank you

then my first formula would apply

Am I right in thinking that you would still have to take into consideration the date in column C could be on the holiday list?

But the author says that the dates are in Col C and they are not adjusted for Holidays

ASKER

Dates in col C are given and they can be coinciding with the list of the dates in the tab 'holidays'.

The idea is to get a formula to do the following:

1. check if the value in tab Examples, col C will coincide with the list in tab Holidays, Col A

2. Then the formula should increment the value in tab Examples, col C by one date

3. Further, the formula should check if the value arrived in step 2 above is working day or a weekend (Saturday or Sunday)

4. If the result of step 4 coincides with weekend, then the formula should increment it by 1 (if sunday)or 2 (if Saturday) to arrive at the next working day Monday.

5. if the result of Step 4 is Monday and a holiday (as per list), then it should increment by 1 day again to result in Tuesday.

Now suppose if as per the default calculation col. c less Col. B results in 2 months,

then by following step 2-5 should also result in 2 months and not 3 months.

Sorry if I have confused the forum and I hope I am clear with my request now.

Kindly help

The idea is to get a formula to do the following:

1. check if the value in tab Examples, col C will coincide with the list in tab Holidays, Col A

2. Then the formula should increment the value in tab Examples, col C by one date

3. Further, the formula should check if the value arrived in step 2 above is working day or a weekend (Saturday or Sunday)

4. If the result of step 4 coincides with weekend, then the formula should increment it by 1 (if sunday)or 2 (if Saturday) to arrive at the next working day Monday.

5. if the result of Step 4 is Monday and a holiday (as per list), then it should increment by 1 day again to result in Tuesday.

Now suppose if as per the default calculation col. c less Col. B results in 2 months,

then by following step 2-5 should also result in 2 months and not 3 months.

Sorry if I have confused the forum and I hope I am clear with my request now.

Kindly help

Hi,

If it does not change the value of the result at the end, why does the formula have to know there is a weekend or a holiday?

If it does not change the value of the result at the end, why does the formula have to know there is a weekend or a holiday?

I agree with RGonzo, I think you are not comparing like with like, comparing whole months with individual days or small groups of days.

How can single or multiple holiday days have an impact on the result? For lapsed months the only way that holidays will have an impact is when you assign a whole month as a holiday.

Thanks

Rob

How can single or multiple holiday days have an impact on the result? For lapsed months the only way that holidays will have an impact is when you assign a whole month as a holiday.

Thanks

Rob

pls try

Open in new window

Shouldn't line 5 be 13 MonthsRegards