asked on Drive configuration in HP DL380 Gen 9
Hello
I was hoping for some advice on drives and configuration for a server I want to spec up.
The server is an HP DL380 Gen 9. part number: 826684-B21
The RAID card in the controller is a HP Smart Array P440ar/2GB FBWC 12Gb 1-port Int SAS Controller
(726736-B21).
I want to put a second internal drive cage for additional storage. But the RAID controller only supports 8 connections (the bay already in there)
I have been told a SAS expander card will do this for me (part number: 727250-B21): I understand this will allow me to fulfil 16 connections... is this correct?
I would like to run 5 times 1.2 TB 10K SAS drives in a RAID 1+0 (with one spare) in drive cage 1. This will be for the operating systems of 4-5 virtual servers (DC, File, Exchange and SQL (SQL DB and logs will be on a different array). I have been led to believe that 10K drives will suffice for this job and to ensure I have a lot of memory. is this true? I think single or dual port drives makes no difference in this config? Also, what about 6G or 12G... I have seen 2 part numbers 781518-B21 and 718162-B21 and the price is pretty much identical. Do I need 12G because the raid controller is 12G?
On the second drive cage I wanted to run 2 arrays. 2 * 480GB SATA SSD's in RAID 1 (twice over) and a hot spare (5 drives in total). 1 array for SQL log files and 1 for SQL Database. Having separate RAID arrays was recommended for the SQL application.
Obviously SATA SSD are about half the price of SAS SSD's! I have read differing opinions. Is this a false economy? I thought running the SATA drives (they will be HP enterprise SATA drives) in a mirror would be ok... I understand they can have problems in RAID 5-6 configurations?
Thanks for any help
I was hoping for some advice on drives and configuration for a server I want to spec up.
The server is an HP DL380 Gen 9. part number: 826684-B21
The RAID card in the controller is a HP Smart Array P440ar/2GB FBWC 12Gb 1-port Int SAS Controller
(726736-B21).
I want to put a second internal drive cage for additional storage. But the RAID controller only supports 8 connections (the bay already in there)
I have been told a SAS expander card will do this for me (part number: 727250-B21): I understand this will allow me to fulfil 16 connections... is this correct?
I would like to run 5 times 1.2 TB 10K SAS drives in a RAID 1+0 (with one spare) in drive cage 1. This will be for the operating systems of 4-5 virtual servers (DC, File, Exchange and SQL (SQL DB and logs will be on a different array). I have been led to believe that 10K drives will suffice for this job and to ensure I have a lot of memory. is this true? I think single or dual port drives makes no difference in this config? Also, what about 6G or 12G... I have seen 2 part numbers 781518-B21 and 718162-B21 and the price is pretty much identical. Do I need 12G because the raid controller is 12G?
On the second drive cage I wanted to run 2 arrays. 2 * 480GB SATA SSD's in RAID 1 (twice over) and a hot spare (5 drives in total). 1 array for SQL log files and 1 for SQL Database. Having separate RAID arrays was recommended for the SQL application.
Obviously SATA SSD are about half the price of SAS SSD's! I have read differing opinions. Is this a false economy? I thought running the SATA drives (they will be HP enterprise SATA drives) in a mirror would be ok... I understand they can have problems in RAID 5-6 configurations?
Thanks for any help
Server HardwareStorage HardwareVirtualization
Last Comment
sfabs
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
THIS SOLUTION ONLY AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS.
View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
SOLUTION
THIS SOLUTION ONLY AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS.
View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
I didnt suggest creating a gig, I dropped my phone and pressed a few buttons picking it up!
ASKER
Phew, that's a relief... a gigs project did sound like a fair amount of work :)
Thanks again for replying Andy.
Thanks for your opinion on the SAS 10K disks... I was thinking that but it's great to see you feel the same.
I am considering SATA SSD's instead of SAS SSD's to save cost... I would love to go for HP Fusion but don't want to increase cost.
The factory installed P440 controller will be responsible for the 5 * 1.2TB (OS array) in a RAID 1+0
Having considered your advice I want to install a second p440 (726736-B21) which is listed as a PCi Express, I think it is identical to the installed card and I believe the server can fit both...?
In the second array card I will create a RAID 1 array for log files as per your advice, using spinning disks, AND create a RAID 1 using the following SATA SSD's for the database; the part number I currently like: 764927-B21 is available at a very good price. Do you think this drive is suitable for the application? (30-40 users reading and writing to an ERP database, I thought the IOPS from an SSD would improve performance of DB)
Thanks again for replying Andy.
Thanks for your opinion on the SAS 10K disks... I was thinking that but it's great to see you feel the same.
I am considering SATA SSD's instead of SAS SSD's to save cost... I would love to go for HP Fusion but don't want to increase cost.
The factory installed P440 controller will be responsible for the 5 * 1.2TB (OS array) in a RAID 1+0
Having considered your advice I want to install a second p440 (726736-B21) which is listed as a PCi Express, I think it is identical to the installed card and I believe the server can fit both...?
In the second array card I will create a RAID 1 array for log files as per your advice, using spinning disks, AND create a RAID 1 using the following SATA SSD's for the database; the part number I currently like: 764927-B21 is available at a very good price. Do you think this drive is suitable for the application? (30-40 users reading and writing to an ERP database, I thought the IOPS from an SSD would improve performance of DB)
SOLUTION
THIS SOLUTION ONLY AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS.
View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
ASKER
Thank you Andy
Yes you are correct... I could fit 8 spinning drives (OS array and SQL logs array with spares) into drive cage 1 plugged into the supplied P440.
Then that seems like a good option of Software RAID on cage 2 for the SATA SSD's running the SQL database. Can i expect the same sort of performance as the hardware RAID of the 440?
I don't expect it to be an exceptionally high write environment, it is an ERP system. Either way I can swallow the price of a replacement drive if it came to it.
Andy thank you very much, my spec has changed considerably from start to finish and I am much more confident now with the spec. The above question is my last
Yes you are correct... I could fit 8 spinning drives (OS array and SQL logs array with spares) into drive cage 1 plugged into the supplied P440.
Then that seems like a good option of Software RAID on cage 2 for the SATA SSD's running the SQL database. Can i expect the same sort of performance as the hardware RAID of the 440?
I don't expect it to be an exceptionally high write environment, it is an ERP system. Either way I can swallow the price of a replacement drive if it came to it.
Andy thank you very much, my spec has changed considerably from start to finish and I am much more confident now with the spec. The above question is my last
SOLUTION
THIS SOLUTION ONLY AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS.
View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
ASKER
thank you for all your help. Brilliant help Andy
ASKER
brilliant level of knowledge and help, thank you Andy
Thank you for your help, I am glad you replied as I had researched a number of questions in the area and found your answers on those questions to be very good.
You have addressed a number of concerns and I appreciate that.
I will take your advice on using spinning disks for transactions logs. Do you fell it is worth using SSD for the SQL database (there will be a balance of reading and writing). Would SATA SSD in a RAID 1 be ok (480GB disks) or do you feel SAS is the only way to go for SSD's in any sort of RAID?
Do you have any concerns regarding using 4 times 1.2TB 10K SAS disks in a RAID 1+0 configuration for the virtualisation of 4 servers? SOmeone suggested I would be better off with 15K disks but the largest 15K disks are 600MB. I understood that with a lot of memory I wouldnt have a problem that they were 10K disks?
thank you again for your time and help
I appreciate the advice on the RAID controller and will also take your advice on a second P440 card instead of the expander card. I wish I could cut down to under 8 drives but I don't see it as a possibility with the numerous arrays requested.