Low Cost Managed Switch

jdff
jdff used Ask the Experts™
on
I have a small network which services get extremely slow at certain times and I have not been able to find the real cause of it, I was wondering if anyone here could recommend a nice managed switch with traffic load monitoring capabilities that won't cost an arm and a leg.
Comment
Watch Question

Do more with

Expert Office
EXPERT OFFICE® is a registered trademark of EXPERTS EXCHANGE®
Aaron TomoskyDirector of Solutions Consulting

Commented:
I'd suggest the Cisco sg line. The 300 if you don't need stacking and the 500 if you do. The free version of prtg with snmp monitoring will give you some pretty good metrics.

Author

Commented:
Hi Aron,
Thank for your advise, however I have no experience on setting up cisco equipment, i would prefer something with a web interface if you have a similar recommendation.
Aaron TomoskyDirector of Solutions Consulting

Commented:
The Cisco sg line is the small business line and it has a web interface as well as CLI.
Expert Spotlight: Joe Anderson (DatabaseMX)

We’ve posted a new Expert Spotlight!  Joe Anderson (DatabaseMX) has been on Experts Exchange since 2006. Learn more about this database architect, guitar aficionado, and Microsoft MVP.

Author

Commented:
So you think I can get an overview of network traffic just by the Managment console, or do I still have to use PRTG?
Aaron TomoskyDirector of Solutions Consulting

Commented:
You can get statistics from the web interface, but separate snmp software will graph over time. Prtg is much easier to setup IMO vs cacti or Rmon or even spiceworks.
Also, be careful about "managed" switches as some have a GUI interface but no SNMP.  I believe the Cisco SG200 series is like that....
Top Expert 2015

Commented:
Cisco might be low-cost (made from cheap parts)
You can buy first hand managed switches from D-LINK or NetGear or LinkSys.
Director of Solutions Consulting
Commented:
IMO
The Cisco sg300 and up are quality, far superior to netgear or dlink smart switches or even fully managed switches.

The sg100 and 200 are a different line and a different story. Plastic parts, slow backplanes, etc...
Top Expert 2015

Commented:
Approx $200 D-Link is cheaper than replacing 'backplane' or 'line card'
Hello

If you want the best product to use and you have no experience working with network devices.
Meraki MS line is what you are looking for.

All port monitoring, traffic, users etc.  Get a 30 day eval, its really easy.
You can also use their Firewall, Access points and phones all together.

Its the best way for your solution going forward.  Anything else you will have to piece meal together and maybe still will not get what you want.

Thanks
nociSoftware Engineer
Distinguished Expert 2018

Commented:
HP 18xx G series are rather cheap but do work quite well.
And do have SNMP.

Author

Commented:
Steve,
I agree with you, Meraki is a great piece of equipment that allows me time to have a margarita under the shade, but it comes with a higher cost, which is no plausible for the SBS.
Thomas AamodtNetwork Architect

Commented:
Meraki is higher cost yes but really good webinterface. but personally i dont like Cisco SG series. but if you need a Webinterface to configure with you should use SG switches.

personaly i whould take a 2960-x or something and learn some commands.
Not hard to enable snmp on a cisco switch.
I didn't say it earlier but I'm using the Cisco SG300 line of switches exclusively for this purpose.
There is nothing complicated or mysterious in setting them up.
Of course, they will "just work" out of the box as if they had no features.
You can add management capabilities at your leisure.
You can avoid more complex capabilities entirely.

Of course these switches aren't as inexpensive as smart/unmanaged switches but they fit the need for "low cost" to me!
Top Expert 2015

Commented:
There is shortage of information what sort of SMART is needed:
MDI-X
SNMP
Routing
VLANs
QoS
Web control panel
Syslog
Netflow
WCCP
....
...

Author

Commented:
Aaron, the Cisco switch was definitely a good solution for the price.

Author

Commented:
Good switch.

Do more with

Expert Office
Submit tech questions to Ask the Experts™ at any time to receive solutions, advice, and new ideas from leading industry professionals.

Start 7-Day Free Trial