• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 190
  • Last Modified:

Need to automate a Thunderbird filter

I can't believe this situation has persisted for years and years: hundreds of postings that the TBird junk service will mark an email as junk but will not move it.  The learning system is pretty good at marking something as junk, but not move it.  Yes, I have read dozens of postings of how-to, etc, so let's just agree it is broken; sometimes moves junk, most times does not.

So I wrote a filter to look for the Junk flag and move the email.  It does that very well.  But I have to manually run it when needed; it does not automatically run, though it is set up to.  So again, dozens of requests for a utility that will schedule a filter to run; no such animal that I can find.

So the bottom line is I am looking for a scheduler that will allow me to schedule my filter to run every few minutes, or even better: run a set number of seconds after email downloads are complete.
0
Mike Caldwell
Asked:
Mike Caldwell
  • 6
  • 5
1 Solution
 
arnoldCommented:
If not mistaken, under filtering. There is a selection the option to auto move junk marked message to junk or another folder.
Which TB version are you using?
0
 
Mike CaldwellDirector of Business Development, AnaquaAuthor Commented:
Yes there is.  That has always been set.  It just doesn't work.  I get roughly 500 junk emails per day amongst all my account.  About one third get moved to the designated Junk folder.  The rest will be tagged as Junk by TB, but it does not move them.  If I untag them, then tag them again, they usually get moved.  If I manually run the Junk filter they get moved.  The bottom line is that TB is pretty good at identifying junk, but does not move it.  There are hundreds of postings found by Google for this same experience, going back many years.  So if I could periodically just run the filter it would be pretty good.  I looked at writing an add-on for TB, but way out of my skill set.  I'm really surprised nobody has done so; thought maybe the E-E crowd would know of one.  There is a set up to automate certain filters, but they trigger on an email coming in; no scheduling feature.
0
 
Mike CaldwellDirector of Business Development, AnaquaAuthor Commented:
My TB version is the latest:  45.4.0.  I generally keep up with updates.  This issue has been in play for as long as I have used TB: about 8 years.
0
Independent Software Vendors: We Want Your Opinion

We value your feedback.

Take our survey and automatically be enter to win anyone of the following:
Yeti Cooler, Amazon eGift Card, and Movie eGift Card!

 
arnoldCommented:
Which type of access do you have to the server pop or IMAP, that might be the issue.
Pop I think was the mechanism that retrieves the messages, and thus can move the message from the local inbox to the local junk folder. In IMAP setup, see if you can configure the filter instead of moving the remote inbox message to the local junk folder, to move from the remote inbox to a remote junk folder.
0
 
Mike CaldwellDirector of Business Development, AnaquaAuthor Commented:
IMAP.  I don't understand the suggestion.  How does one specify local or remote?  In the interest of speed, I do have it configured to keep a local copy of the folders.  However I recall that when I explored this a few years ago the recommendation was for the Junk folder for all accounts to be a local folder.  If that is your suggestion, I'll give that a go and report.
0
 
arnoldCommented:
When your account configured as IMAP, to actually accesses the remote server for the message while getting headers down.
Add an IMAP folder junk, then configure your spam filter to move to the IMAP spam folder.

The issue is that for the junk filter to work, it needs access to the full message.

IMAP makes the movement of spam designated email more complicated, it is a multi step process involving notifying the server that the message in the inbox should be deleted.......
0
 
Mike CaldwellDirector of Business Development, AnaquaAuthor Commented:
I defined a new Junk filter under the Inbox of one of my five accounts, then set all of their Junk filters to move Junk to that folder.  So far, so good.
0
 
Mike CaldwellDirector of Business Development, AnaquaAuthor Commented:
A few are still going to the old (local) Junk folder, but at least they are all moving SOMEWHERE now.  Thanks much.
0
 
arnoldCommented:
Glad I could help.
0
 
Mike CaldwellDirector of Business Development, AnaquaAuthor Commented:
Stopped working altogether!  Did fine for a week or so, now just like before.  I find that if I do "Properties >  Repair Folder" for each of my five email Inboxes then it will work for a while.
0
 
arnoldCommented:
I am uncertain on where the statistical data is stored on which basis the incoming is analyzed. Not sure it was designed to perform spam detection on IMAP type accounts.
Many email providers have their own anti-spam measures, check whether each has a server level anti-spamming measure you can activate ....
0

Featured Post

VIDEO: THE CONCERTO CLOUD FOR HEALTHCARE

Modern healthcare requires a modern cloud. View this brief video to understand how the Concerto Cloud for Healthcare can help your organization.

  • 6
  • 5
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now