Want to protect your cyber security and still get fast solutions? Ask a secure question today.Go Premium

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 65
  • Last Modified:

SQL Query Using 1 column to group by with multiple columns in query

I have the following view that I am trying to group by the column called fHEATNO but also show the other columns in the view with it. But it's telling me that the other fields are not part of an aggregate function. How can I group this by the fHEATNO column and still show the others? If there are multiple fHEATNO values then I can use the first record of those with multiple records with the same fHEATNO.


SELECT     TOP (100) PERCENT LTRIM(RTRIM(fHEATNO)) AS HEATNo, FSUFFIX, FVENDNO, FCOMPANY, FELEMC, FELEMMN, FELEMSI, FELEMP, FELEMS, FELEMCR, FELEMNI, 
                      FELEMMO, FELEMCU, FELEMCBTA, FELEMTI, FELEMCO, FELEMAL, FELEMSE, FELEMSN, FELEMV, FELEMN, FELEMB, FYIELDSTR1, FTENSILE1, FELONG1, 
                      FREDUC1, FSHIPHARD1, FHARDENABLE1, FMICROSTRUC1, FMACROTECH1, FGRSIZE1, FULTRASON1, FYIELDSTR2, FTENSILE2, FELONG2, FREDUC2, 
                      FSHIPHARD2, FHARDENABLE2, FMICROSTRUC2, FMACROTECH2, FGRSIZE2, FULTRASON2, RTRIM(FCAPABILITY) AS FCAPABILITY, FMILL, FCREATEDATE, 
                      FCOMMENTS, FPARTNO, FMELTTEMP, FHTTRTCOND, FCHANGEDATE, FMELTSOURCE, FCOUNTRY, FHEATLOT, FOVLOT, FCUSTHEATNO
FROM         dbo.HEATDATA
WHERE     (fHEATNO <> '')
GROUP BY fHEATNO
ORDER BY fHEATNO

Open in new window

0
Lawrence Salvucci
Asked:
Lawrence Salvucci
  • 3
  • 3
1 Solution
 
PortletPaulCommented:
The error message is telling you that GROUP BY must contain EVERY column that isn't using an aggregate function such as SUM() COUNT() MIN() MAX() etc.

This is by design and isn't a fault.

To achieve what I think you want needs a different technique, and I suggest ROW_NUMBER() for this. HOWEVER I will be guessing some of the detail.
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
Not that familiar with ROW_NUMBER. There are some fHEATNO values that are the same along with almost every other field except for the fpartno field. That would be the only one that would be different and I really don't need that field anyways. So how could I achieve to group these using the ROW_NUMBER?
0
 
PortletPaulCommented:
You need to consider what conditions form "the first row". I have chosen a date column in descending order (so you get the "most recent" row) but as I don't know your data at all this is a guess:
SELECT
        *
FROM (SELECT
                LTRIM(RTRIM(fHEATNO))                                 AS HEATNo
              , ROW_NUMBER() OVER (PARTITION BY LTRIM(RTRIM(fHEATNO)) 
\                                  ORDER BY FCHANGEDATE DESC)         AS rn
              , FSUFFIX
              , FVENDNO
              , FCOMPANY
              , FELEMC
              , FELEMMN
              , FELEMSI
              , FELEMP
              , FELEMS
              , FELEMCR
              , FELEMNI
              , FELEMMO
              , FELEMCU
              , FELEMCBTA
              , FELEMTI
              , FELEMCO
              , FELEMAL
              , FELEMSE
              , FELEMSN
              , FELEMV
              , FELEMN
              , FELEMB
              , FYIELDSTR1
              , FTENSILE1
              , FELONG1
              , FREDUC1
              , FSHIPHARD1
              , FHARDENABLE1
              , FMICROSTRUC1
              , FMACROTECH1
              , FGRSIZE1
              , FULTRASON1
              , FYIELDSTR2
              , FTENSILE2
              , FELONG2
              , FREDUC2
              , FSHIPHARD2
              , FHARDENABLE2
              , FMICROSTRUC2
              , FMACROTECH2
              , FGRSIZE2
              , FULTRASON2
              , RTRIM(FCAPABILITY) AS FCAPABILITY
              , FMILL
              , FCREATEDATE
              , FCOMMENTS
              , FPARTNO
              , FMELTTEMP
              , FHTTRTCOND
              , FCHANGEDATE
              , FMELTSOURCE
              , FCOUNTRY
              , FHEATLOT
              , FOVLOT
              , FCUSTHEATNO
        FROM dbo.HEATDATA
        WHERE (fHEATNO <> '')
    ) AS D


WHERE RN = 1

Open in new window

Please note I do NOT recommend using ORDER BY in views, you should only apply an order by in the final select query. Using order in views is a performance problem.
0
Independent Software Vendors: We Want Your Opinion

We value your feedback.

Take our survey and automatically be enter to win anyone of the following:
Yeti Cooler, Amazon eGift Card, and Movie eGift Card!

 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
The date column will work fine as the first record for the duplicates. I will test that out and post back shortly. I didn't know that about the ORDER BY in a view. Can that really impact the performance in a noticeable way?
0
 
PortletPaulCommented:
Think about the ORDER BY this way....

select *
from atable t
inner join aview v on a.id = v.fk
where t.x = 'y' and v.cdate >= '20160101'
order by t.something, v.someother

any order by in that view is wasted effort because
1. you are joining to it
2. you filter out many rows
3. end up with a different order anyway
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
That makes sense. I'll have to go through all my views and remove the ORDER BY. Thank you for that insight! Appreciate it. And your query syntax works exactly how I wanted it to. Thank you very much!!
0

Featured Post

Free Tool: SSL Checker

Scans your site and returns information about your SSL implementation and certificate. Helpful for debugging and validating your SSL configuration.

One of a set of tools we are providing to everyone as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

  • 3
  • 3
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now