We help IT Professionals succeed at work.

Can ping from Switch but not from PC

TFGreen
TFGreen asked
on
1,385 Views
Last Modified: 2018-01-15
running into a current problem where my 10+ years of routing and switching experience is drawing a major blank (embarassed).

i have an HP procurve environment comprised of a core with a highly subnetted 192.168.x.x/24

I have a need to connect us up to a different network made up of a bunch or extreme switches on a 172.16.101.x/24 network for switch management on vlan 400.

I have been able to trunk vlan 400 from the hp to the extreme network.

From my core switch (or any switch that has vlan 400 on it) I can ping any switch address on the 172.16.101.x network so I know i have vlan 400 passed all the way through to the extreme network

From my pc I can not ping any of the 172.16.101.x switch addresses

What stupidly obvious thing here am I drawing a blank on.

Thanks in advance.
Comment
Watch Question

AlexA lack of information provides a lack of a decent solution.
CERTIFIED EXPERT

Commented:
Windows firewall? Leave the service running but disable it on your lan card, just to rule it out

Author

Commented:
thank you - windows firewall is disabled by default

Author

Commented:
simple drawing of procurve switch connecivity to the extreme switch network.  All over vlan 400
Freelancer - IT Specialist
Commented:
This problem has been solved!
(Unlock this solution with a 7-day Free Trial)
UNLOCK SOLUTION

Author

Commented:
But if any HP switch on vlan 400 can ping any extreme switch on vlan 400 on the other network would that really be in play?
GammelgaardFreelancer - IT Specialist

Commented:
Well, the traceroute will tell you.. Do one from your pc and one from the Core router and compare

Author

Commented:
trace route from core and pc attached - core is immedeate and pc never makes it

2017-03-07_8-53-22.png2017-03-07_8-53-41.png
GammelgaardFreelancer - IT Specialist

Commented:
The routing device handling the return packet needs to know of your 192.168.x.x net

Author

Commented:
so the extreme core would need a route in it to point back to the 192.168 network?
GammelgaardFreelancer - IT Specialist

Commented:
That's my best bet
GammelgaardFreelancer - IT Specialist

Commented:
That's my best bet

Author

Commented:
you might be onto something - I could not ping the HP network from the extreme until I just added this route into the extreme network and not the extreme can ping the HP network - but still can't ping the extreme net from a pc yet

2017-03-07_9-09-52.png
GammelgaardFreelancer - IT Specialist

Commented:
Put a route for extreme net into your own core - also check the ACLs, if any

Author

Commented:
all fixed - thank you
MikeIT Professional
CERTIFIED EXPERT

Commented:
This question has been classified as abandoned and is closed as part of the Cleanup Program. See the recommendation for more details.