Fred Marie
asked on
Exchange 2013 - Cluster/Failover not working properly
Hi all,
First question here :) And an odd one!
Hope one of you guys saw this issue before.
I have an exchange (2013) DAG, with 3 servers (2012 R2). As far as I can tell, everything is setup fine (well, it has been for a few years now!) but very recently (about a month), when one of the server goes down (let's say a reboot, or even an IIS restart!) all the Outlook clients disconnect! Even if the server does not have live mailboxes.
This only happens for one server. When I reboot any of the other 2, the failover happens as usual if the client database is hosted on that particular server.
So, that one is a first for me, and as far as I can tell, everything is setup as it should be, and config does match the other 2 servers.
Any pointers?
Many thanks,
Fred
First question here :) And an odd one!
Hope one of you guys saw this issue before.
I have an exchange (2013) DAG, with 3 servers (2012 R2). As far as I can tell, everything is setup fine (well, it has been for a few years now!) but very recently (about a month), when one of the server goes down (let's say a reboot, or even an IIS restart!) all the Outlook clients disconnect! Even if the server does not have live mailboxes.
This only happens for one server. When I reboot any of the other 2, the failover happens as usual if the client database is hosted on that particular server.
So, that one is a first for me, and as far as I can tell, everything is setup as it should be, and config does match the other 2 servers.
Any pointers?
Many thanks,
Fred
ASKER
Hi Mahesh,
Thanks for your inputs.
I can confirm that this server does not hold active database.
I do agree, usually the disconnection last for about 5 seconds max in our environment. But in this particular case, the clients disconnects for as long as the server goes down.
Either by a server restart, or an IIS reset/restart.
This does not make any sense to me I have to say! :(
Thanks for your inputs.
I can confirm that this server does not hold active database.
I do agree, usually the disconnection last for about 5 seconds max in our environment. But in this particular case, the clients disconnects for as long as the server goes down.
Either by a server restart, or an IIS reset/restart.
This does not make any sense to me I have to say! :(
does you have HA established for CAS servers? and what kind of HA is configured? DNS round robin or HLB or NLB which one?
If NLB or HLB is configured, you should not face issue, however if round robin is configured, then you might face issue if TTL value for CAS server record is more, in that case reconnection is not possible until server come online
However to isolate the issue, on client machine from outlook client taskbar icon, right click while holding CTRL key and go to connection status. There you would find the CAS server, client is connected to. if this server is different from failed server, you can reset IIS / reboot failed server again and check if still client is getting impacted, it should not.
If NLB or HLB is configured, you should not face issue, however if round robin is configured, then you might face issue if TTL value for CAS server record is more, in that case reconnection is not possible until server come online
However to isolate the issue, on client machine from outlook client taskbar icon, right click while holding CTRL key and go to connection status. There you would find the CAS server, client is connected to. if this server is different from failed server, you can reset IIS / reboot failed server again and check if still client is getting impacted, it should not.
ASKER
Hi Maresh,
We are using DNS+HLB(kemp), but good point, haven't checked that, but I have a look now, although, no changes made that I am aware of.
For your second part, whichever server my DB is live on, it does not matter, as soon as I put this particular box offline, all clients disconnects until this one comes back. If id do that to the other 2 servers in the cluster, failover occurs just fine. In the config window, when I hit reconnect while the server is offline, it does not, like when this server is offile, Outlook lose all connectivity to the entire cluster... very odd!
I did a failover cluster validation, and all came back clear minus the "usual" issues, but nothing odd from my historical data.
I am lost on that one I have to say!
We are using DNS+HLB(kemp), but good point, haven't checked that, but I have a look now, although, no changes made that I am aware of.
For your second part, whichever server my DB is live on, it does not matter, as soon as I put this particular box offline, all clients disconnects until this one comes back. If id do that to the other 2 servers in the cluster, failover occurs just fine. In the config window, when I hit reconnect while the server is offline, it does not, like when this server is offile, Outlook lose all connectivity to the entire cluster... very odd!
I did a failover cluster validation, and all came back clear minus the "usual" issues, but nothing odd from my historical data.
I am lost on that one I have to say!
can you let me know what role each of your servers hosting including DAG and number of database copies
also what about autodiscover, mail.domain.com record, it is pointing to which servers
Also I don,t understood how (KEMP + DNS), how both are in place
also what about autodiscover, mail.domain.com record, it is pointing to which servers
Also I don,t understood how (KEMP + DNS), how both are in place
ASKER
All 3 servers are:
ServerRole : Mailbox, ClientAccess
Each with 12 DB copies, all healthy.
DAG has 3 nodes (server 1, 2 and 3), and currently hosted on server#3. Issue is with server#2
I check the DNS, but I believe mail.domain.com point to the virtual IP in Kemp and autodiscover to all 3 IPs, but have to confirm, this is on top of my head.
For Kemp/DNS, this was done before my time here, but I believe HLD+DNS is the recommended setup from MS, but don't mark my word! :)
ServerRole : Mailbox, ClientAccess
Each with 12 DB copies, all healthy.
DAG has 3 nodes (server 1, 2 and 3), and currently hosted on server#3. Issue is with server#2
I check the DNS, but I believe mail.domain.com point to the virtual IP in Kemp and autodiscover to all 3 IPs, but have to confirm, this is on top of my head.
For Kemp/DNS, this was done before my time here, but I believe HLD+DNS is the recommended setup from MS, but don't mark my word! :)
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
No comment has been added to this question in more than 21 days, so it is now classified as abandoned.
I have recommended this question be closed as follows:
Accept: Mahesh (https:#a42423438)
If you feel this question should be closed differently, post an objection and the moderators will review all objections and close it as they feel fit. If no one objects, this question will be closed automatically the way described above.
seth2740
Experts-Exchange Cleanup Volunteer
I have recommended this question be closed as follows:
Accept: Mahesh (https:#a42423438)
If you feel this question should be closed differently, post an objection and the moderators will review all objections and close it as they feel fit. If no one objects, this question will be closed automatically the way described above.
seth2740
Experts-Exchange Cleanup Volunteer
if server have passive copies of databases and if that only server goes down, there should not be an impact
You need to check if server has active copy got activated due to automated mailbox database activation etc
Also if this is CAS server, it might possible that your clients are connected to this server and got disconnected after server rebooted as CAS is responsible for proxying connections to mailbox server, the disconnection would be time being for very short period in that case