Migrating Xenapp servers from Citrix Xenserver to VMWare
First of all, let me say that I'm primarily a VMWare person, and have very little experience with Citrix except for the situation I'm describing in this post.
About 2 years ago, we signed a client who is using Citrix Xenserver on three host machines. Two are running Xenserver 6.1 and one we upgraded last year to Xenserver 7.0. As we had planned from the beginning, we want to migrate all of their VMs from these three Xenservers to two host machines running VMware. Their VMs are all Windows 2008 R2 except for one Windows 2012 R2 that we added last year to run SQL. They currently have two servers running Citrix Xenapp 6.5, and these servers are extraordinarily underutilized. The reality of the situation is that the Xenapp capabilities are only being used by a few firm employees to work remotely occasionally at night or on weekends.
My migration plan's end result would be two hosts running the latest version of ESXi with a vSphere Essentials license. I have done a lot of research and found lots of posts and helpful information on the pitfalls of migrating Citrix VMs to VMware, so I think I'm OK on that portion of the migration. However, if anyone has any very recent experience with this, i.e., migrating to ESXi 6.5 or 6.7, and has something to add specific to those versions of VMWare, I would be glad to have the extra input.
I have some questions regarding migrating the Xenapp servers:
1. Are there any issues running Xenapp on Windows VMs hosted on VMware?
2. Is it possible to remove the Xenapp components and reconfigure these servers as straight Windows RDS servers without having to start from scratch? And if so, can you point me to any documentation regarding the process?
3. If we decide to keep using Citrix Xenapp after the migration, is there any trick to removing the secondary server from the farm, since it's clearly not needed? Again, any documentation would be helpful.
About 2 years ago, we signed a client who is using Citrix Xenserver on three host machines. Two are running Xenserver 6.1 and one we upgraded last year to Xenserver 7.0. As we had planned from the beginning, we want to migrate all of their VMs from these three Xenservers to two host machines running VMware. Their VMs are all Windows 2008 R2 except for one Windows 2012 R2 that we added last year to run SQL. They currently have two servers running Citrix Xenapp 6.5, and these servers are extraordinarily underutilized. The reality of the situation is that the Xenapp capabilities are only being used by a few firm employees to work remotely occasionally at night or on weekends.
My migration plan's end result would be two hosts running the latest version of ESXi with a vSphere Essentials license. I have done a lot of research and found lots of posts and helpful information on the pitfalls of migrating Citrix VMs to VMware, so I think I'm OK on that portion of the migration. However, if anyone has any very recent experience with this, i.e., migrating to ESXi 6.5 or 6.7, and has something to add specific to those versions of VMWare, I would be glad to have the extra input.
I have some questions regarding migrating the Xenapp servers:
1. Are there any issues running Xenapp on Windows VMs hosted on VMware?
2. Is it possible to remove the Xenapp components and reconfigure these servers as straight Windows RDS servers without having to start from scratch? And if so, can you point me to any documentation regarding the process?
3. If we decide to keep using Citrix Xenapp after the migration, is there any trick to removing the secondary server from the farm, since it's clearly not needed? Again, any documentation would be helpful.
Do more with
EXPERT OFFICE® is a registered trademark of EXPERTS EXCHANGE®
1. Nope, no, none
2. Google, "manually uninstall XenApp 6.5". Follow the Citrix article but also read the article from Jacob Rutski. I have used those two articles several times to remove all the XA65 components and then "upgrade" the servers to XenApp 7.15 LTSR. Straight RDS doesn't have the built-in load balancing that XenApp has. Once the XA65 components are uninstalled, RDS is left. Will not impact apps at all.
3. Run the XenApp install program (sorry can't remember the name, but it should be on the start menu) and select the option Remove from Farm. Requires a server restart.
2. Google, "manually uninstall XenApp 6.5". Follow the Citrix article but also read the article from Jacob Rutski. I have used those two articles several times to remove all the XA65 components and then "upgrade" the servers to XenApp 7.15 LTSR. Straight RDS doesn't have the built-in load balancing that XenApp has. Once the XA65 components are uninstalled, RDS is left. Will not impact apps at all.
3. Run the XenApp install program (sorry can't remember the name, but it should be on the start menu) and select the option Remove from Farm. Requires a server restart.
Thanks, I'll take a look at those articles and get back with any questions. On your comment about RDS not having as good load-balancing as Xenapp. I can't comment since I don't have extensive experience with Xenapp. However, since as I said there are only a few employees who use the RDS capabilities and only a few times a week at most, I'm not much concerned about that. I've done a number of Windows 2008/2012/2016 RDS configurations in similar user environments and haven't encountered any load-balancing issues. My objective is to simplify the layers that have to be managed and from that POV a Windows RDS server would be simpler, since I'm very familiar with that environment and not so much with Xenapp.
Premium Content
You need an Expert Office subscription to comment.Start Free Trial