Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of snoopaloop
snoopaloopFlag for United States of America

asked on

Basic Power Distribution Unit vs fancy PDU

How important is a 2.9kW Single-Phase ATS / Metered (Switched PDU) PDU, 120V Outlets (24 5-15/20R, 1 L5-30R), 2 L5-30P, 2 10ft Cords, 2U Rack-Mount, TAA from some company like Tripplite in a small server enviornment?  We are talk 2 - 3 servers plus some routers and switches.  It looks like a fancy device that does not deliver UPS features.    I think this is more what I need but this fancy PDU was offered in a quote so I figured I get acquainted with it before shutting it down...  

  • Tripp Lite PDU Basic 120V 2.9kW 30A 5-15R 24 Outlet L5-30P Horizontal 1URM - horizontal rackmount - power distribution unit - 2.9 kW
  • SmartPro LCD 120V 1500VA 900W Line-Interactive UPS, AVR, 2U Rack/Tower, LCD, USB, DB9 Serial, 8 Outlets
Avatar of David Favor
David Favor
Flag of United States of America image

TAA only applies to political or ethical policy, so importance relies on your moral compass.

If "It looks like a fancy device that does not deliver UPS features" is true, I'd personally pass on this device.

Give me a simple/separate UPS on every device capable of a few hours battery life over fancy devices any day.
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of kevinhsieh
kevinhsieh
Flag of United States of America image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of Member_2_231077
Member_2_231077

Googling for the description suggests it is an ATS rather than a basic PDU, they are rarely needed since most equipment has dual PSUs anyway to connect to two separate power feeds.

"Super-fast switchover between primary and secondary power sources occurs within milliseconds" so some PSUs will cope with the switchover but others the server will crash anyway. It has individual switched outputs, as it is on Ethernet that is useful for rebooting things remotely if they hang up. Programmable too so you can sequence power up so the routers and switches are up before the servers turn on after a power cut for example. Optional environmental monitoring unit, useful but you have thermal sensors in the servers you can read anyway.

So it's better than a power strip but also costs more.
I would like to point out that while many servers have dual power supplies, a significant majority of networking gear only has a single AC power input. Much Cisco enterprise gear has option for a second DC input, and I have firewalls costing tens of thousands of dollars with a single power supply. I also have newer baby firewalls with dual power supply inputs.
Indeed, on the network side you often provide redundancy by having two switches and two routers instead but still one is powered from left and one from right PDU.
Avatar of snoopaloop

ASKER

Thank you, this was very helpful.