We help IT Professionals succeed at work.

Trying to write a SumProduct formula (using double negative method ) in VBA

I'm trying to recreate this formula in VBA and getting a "Type mismatch" error. Able to do it via R1C1 and then .filldown, but explicitly trying to avoid that has it's super slow in the real data set.

Can't figure out what I'm doing wrong. I've used this method in simpler SumIf formulas before...

Sub WriteFormulas()
    
    Dim rQnty As Range, rName As Range, rDate As Range
    Dim vQnty As Variant, vName As Variant, vDate As Variant
    Dim j As Double, dValue As Double

    With ThisWorkbook.Worksheets(1)
        Set rQnty = .Range("A2:A10")
        Set rName = .Range("B2:B10")
        Set rDate = .Range("C2:C10")
    End With
        
    vQnty = rQnty.Value
    vName = rName.Value
    vDate = rDate.Value
    
    For j = 1 To UBound(vQnty)
        dValue = WorksheetFunction.SumProduct((rQnty), --(rName = vName(j, 1)), --(rDate = vDate(j, 1)))
    Next j
   
    'Range("D2").FormulaR1C1 = "=SUMPRODUCT(RC[-3]:R[8]C[-3],--(RC[-2]:R[8]C[-2]=""John""),--(RC[-1]:R[8]C[-1]=""Jan""))"
   
End Sub

Open in new window

Capture.PNG
Comment
Watch Question

byundtMechanical Engineer
Most Valuable Expert 2013
Top Expert 2013

Commented:
SUMPRODUCT does not work well in VBA. As flexible as it is in a worksheet formula, it must be handled with kid gloves in VBA.
  • VBA will not accept multiplying one parameter by another. You must separate each parameter with commas.
  • VBA will not accept Boolean expressions as one of the parameters. But you are able to use the Evaluate method to convert the Boolean expression into something that SUMPRODUCT will accept.

I wrote up the results of some extensive testing in this old EE thread:
Analyst Assistant
Commented:
You could try using Evaluate, though it is a bit messy.
    For j = 1 To UBound(vQnty)
        dValue = Evaluate("SUMPRODUCT(" & rQnty.Address & ",--(" & rName.Address & "=""" & vName(j, 1) & """), --(" & rDate.Address & "=""" & vDate(j, 1) & """))")
    Next j

Open in new window

Author

Commented:
Yes, that works! Thank You

byundt, the link to the N function was interesting but couldn't get it to work....

Norie, it doesn't seem to work when the Date column is actual dates, like 9/4/2019, even after format(date,"mm/dd/yyyy"). Any idea around that?
NorieAnalyst Assistant

Commented:
Strange, it worked for me.

Might be something to do with regional settings or something like that - I'll have a look when I get a chance.