Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of nickg5
nickg5Flag for United States of America

asked on

Rebuttal or counter argument

Back in late 2019 I think it was I entered the church and while in the lobby a child approached me from the hallway. The age was 6. They walked right up to me and said "you weren't here last Sunday." I was not exactly prepared for such a thing and if it had been an adult I'd been offended. I had maybe 1-2 seconds to reply and all I could say was "I was not able to be here last week. Thank you for telling me about it."

This child is a member of a family that has to be at church each week due to the duties of one of the members. Pending an illness or out of town that family is there every week. By the way I'm not the only one who cannot attend each week.

This child's philosophy (?) has been shared with their siblings (ages 9-11-13). The older one greets me every time I see them at church or away from church. The other three walk right past me like I'm invisible. Back in September 2021 I was attending a party and I was sitting at the end of a table with the father of the 6 year old who was 8 at the time. The child came to the end of the table and stood there. Their father in Spanish said something to the child and the last word in the father's comments was my name. I think he asked his child why he did not greet me. The child responded in Spanish and their father replied again in maybe 2-3 sentences and again my name was the last word. The child picked up their hotdog plate and walked off. I talked to the father and the oldest child maybe 8 weeks later and reminded the father of September 11 and he wanted to tell me there was no problem though I believed there was by the conversation he had with his child on 9-11-21. I am not sure what my rebuttal or counter argument should be to try to solve this issue with the child. I give all 13 of the kids at church a small birthday gift with the approval of their parents. The youngest child has only said one thing to me since July 31 and that was to ask me how to set the digital watch I gave them for their birthday. The 11 year old has not spoken to me since August 2 except to thank me for the gift I gave them at their mid November birthday party which I did attend. And the 9 year old (at the time now age 10) has not spoken to me since July 31.


 I am not sure what my rebuttal or counter argument should be to try to solve this issue with the child.  


The pastor can not be trusted to help on this matter because they like to use prompting and they like to fix things and they use horrendous tricks or whatever to accomplish their goal of fixing. Prompting is to tell someone to do something that person has stopped (or don't want to do) doing because they think the promptee is hoping or expecting it. Example. In early 2021 the youngest child was hanging around the pastor at the front of the sanctuary for a couple Sundays. Then like magic a week later this child greets me at church. Two weeks later they stopped. The pastor had prompted them to do it and it failed to fix and the child went back to their desired behavior. One of my pet peeves is prompting because it's phony and not sincere and because the person (chosen as the prompter) wanted to do it. 

ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of Dr. Klahn
Dr. Klahn

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Given what you have shared, I don't think that there is a rebuttal or counter argument that will be productive.  It doesn't sound as if logic will work here.
You can't impose your will on others (the pastor is misguided)
You should accept things that you cannot change.
Use the AA Serenity Prayer to guide yourself
God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, The courage to change the things I can, And the wisdom to know the difference. 
Avatar of nickg5

ASKER

This child has acquired their own idea that everyone should be at church every week. The have expressed this with their actions of not speaking to me. Their siblings tagging along. I'm not sure about the parents but I'm going to assume they don't know about it.
I hate to lose friendship with this family of six.
SOLUTION
Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of nickg5

ASKER

The family is being controlled by their pastor in a harmful way = puppets. That is a root of the problem. On top of that is this child who with his two siblings walk past you like you are invisible going back many months. Who wants to experience that? The parents and oldest child are friendly as far as handshake and how you doing. Even though >>>> another is the way the current members treat former members. They don't associate with them (see *) and events for which past members were invited those invites are gone.

 * It's the pastor and I refer to Jeremiah 23:1.
This pastor has scattered 31 and I can name all 31 and sadly the pastor can not. Why not? They are blind to their actions. They used Wikipedia to create a scenario for the 10-15-20 years into the future and caused this massive scattering of sheep. As one former member said: "the pastor is a democrat and democrats are Satan." Amen.
SOLUTION
Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of nickg5

ASKER

The part about politics was the comment of someone who left the church 3+ years ago.
----------
I commend the 8 year old for their devotion but for them to pass by people as if they are invisible is not christian like.
SOLUTION
Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of nickg5

ASKER

At some point in time I'll try this or at least let the parent hear it.
"Sorry.  I didn't know that this is the only place where you allow God to exist."

What the parent does with the thought is unfortunately only partially up to them. They are puppets to the pastor.
I have written proof. Oh well.